Week 1 · Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world · 3 lessons
1
Who decides what I do online?
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9SW.05
GoalWeigh the arguments for and against adult rules for teenagers online, and explain who shares responsibility.
New words
responsibility · a duty to make good choices and to answer for what happens because of themregulate · to control something with rulesconsequence · something that happens because of a choiceterms of use · the rules a website or app asks you to accept before you join
Explanation
How much say should adults have in a 13-year-old’s life online? People disagree, and both sides have reasons. Some say teenagers are old enough to learn by trying. Others say a mistake online can last for years, so adults should guide. Many countries have laws about the age at which a child can agree to share data with online services, often between 13 and 16, and apps set their own minimum ages in their terms of use. A law or a rule cannot make every choice for you. Parents, teachers, the app and the law each do a part, but you click the buttons. That is why the person who posts carries responsibility for what is posted. Responsibility grows with practice, and asking an adult is part of being responsible, not a sign of weakness.
Who
What they can do
Law
sets age limits and protects data
App or website
sets rules and gives report and block tools
Parent or carer
agrees family rules and helps when things go wrong
Teacher or school
teaches safe habits and sets school rules
You
decide what to post, open, share and say
Worked examples
Amir
I’m 14. I should decide myself. I only chat with friends.
Aunt Dilya
Friends can share your words with people you have never met.
Two voices in a family debate. Amir wants freedom, and his aunt wants rules. Each gives a reason.
Freedom from adult rules
Adult guidance
learn to decide for yourself
stops serious mistakes while you learn
more privacy
someone to ask when a message feels wrong
feels trusted
clear limits for sleep and school time
A balance sheet of the two sides. A good argument names a benefit or a risk and gives a reason.
I choose to post→The app shows it to others→Others can copy it→I answer for the result
Responsibility is shared, but it does not disappear. When Sara posts a photo of her class trip, the app, her school and her family all play a part, and the choice to post is still hers.
Class activity
Two-sided debate (with a family member or classmate, on paper). Write on a sheet: ‘A 13-year-old should decide alone how to use the internet.’ Draw two columns, For and Against. Write three reasons in each, each with ‘because’. Argue one side for two minutes, then swap sides. At the end, write one rule you think is fair for 13–14-year-olds and who should check it. Do not use real names of other people in your notes. If you have a computer or tablet, type your final rule in two sentences.
Practice
1
Choose the stronger argument and say why. (a) ‘Adults should have no say, because I am clever.’ (b) ‘Some limits help me, because a post can be copied and cannot be fully taken back.’
Argument
(a)
Adults should have no say, because I am clever.
(b)
Some limits help me, because a post can be copied and cannot be fully taken back.
(b) is stronger. It names a real fact (posts can be copied and are hard to remove) and a reason. (a) is only a claim about cleverness and gives no evidence.
2
Name three groups that share responsibility for a teenager’s online safety, and one thing each can do.
Answers will vary – look for: parent or carer (family rules, helps when upset), school (teaches safe habits), app (report and block tools), law (age limits, data protection). The pupil also chooses what to post.
3
A site says ‘You must be 13 to join’. Ali is 11 and says ‘Everyone in my class has joined, so it must be fine.’ Explain what is wrong with this reasoning.
Ali
Everyone in my class has joined, so it must be fine.
Other people breaking a rule does not make it safe. Age limits exist for reasons such as data protection and content. Ali should talk to a parent or carer, and not join until he is old enough.
4
Is the saying ‘my phone, my choice, so no one else is responsible’ fully true? Give one reason for and one against.
Partly. For: you press ‘post’. Against: other people may be affected by what you post, and adults and apps also have duties to help and protect you. Responsibility is shared, but you always carry your own part.