Week 4 Ā· Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world Ā· 3 lessons
1
Same search, different page
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9SW.02
GoalExplain how two people can get different results for the same search and name the data that causes it.
New words
personalised Ā· changed to suit one personās datarelevant Ā· closely connected to what a person wantsranking Ā· the order in which results are listedlanguage setting Ā· the language a device or app is set to use
Explanation
Two classmates type the same words into a search engine and the pages do not match. Why? The search engine does not only match words. It also uses data about each person: past searches and clicks, location, device, language and time of day. A pupil who often reads about football may see football shops first when searching ābootsā. A pupil in a rainy city may see waterproof walking boots. This is personalisation, and its stated aim is to give more relevant results. It can be helpful. But it also means you cannot be sure that your results are the same as other peopleās, or that you have seen everything. Searching with different words, or on a shared library computer where your history is not stored, can show you what else exists.
Same words
Data used
Result list
ābootsā
football fan, city A
football boots first
ābootsā
hiker, mountain town B
walking boots first
Worked examples
Pupil A and pupil B search for ābootsā. This is what A sees.
This is what pupil B sees for the same search. The order and the pages are different.
Data
Pupil A
Pupil B
Past searches
football fixtures
hiking routes
Location
a big city
a mountain town
Device
tablet
phone
Why they differ. Each person leaves different data, and the engine uses it.
Class activity
Two-searcher drawing (on paper). Draw two stick people with thought bubbles: one loves cooking, one loves cycling. Both search ābikeā or āpanā (choose one word). Draw the search result page each might see, with three results each. Write under each page the data you think caused it. Then write one question you would ask a search engine to reduce bubbles, for example āCould I see the other personās list?ā Discuss with a partner whether it matters if results differ. No searching needed.
Practice
1
Two pupils search for āmouseā. One has been reading about pets, the other about computer equipment. What might each see first?
Pupil
Reads about
Types
Dara
pets
āmouseā
Yan
computer equipment
āmouseā
The pet reader may see pages about the small animal, the other pupil may see pages about computer mice. The engine uses past searches to guess what each person means.
2
Name four kinds of data that might change search results.
Past searches, past clicks, location, device, language, time of day. Any four are correct.
3
A pupil says āMy result list must be the true list of the best pages.ā Explain why this might not be true.
Lena
My result list must be the true list of the best pages.
It is a list ranked for that pupil using their data, adverts and other factors. Another person may see a different order, and the first result is not always the best.
4
Why can personalised results be useful and also a problem? Give one of each.
Useful: relevant results appear quickly. Problem: you may miss useful pages or other viewpoints that the system thought you did not want.