Week 12 Ā· Unit 9.2: My childrenās digital world Ā· 3 lessons
1
What AI does well
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.2, objectives 9DW.06, 9TC.04
GoalDescribe real benefits of AI and say why each one still needs people to check the result.
New words
benefit Ā· a good result or advantageaccessibility Ā· making things usable by people with different needs, such as hearing, sight or languagecaption Ā· text that appears on screen to show what is being saidassist Ā· to help a person do a job; the person stays responsible
Explanation
AI is useful because it can look through huge amounts of data far faster than a person. In health care, a program trained on many scans can mark places a doctor should look at more closely. In accessibility, AI tools can add captions to speech, read text aloud and translate between languages, so more people can join in. On farms and in factories, AI can spot a worn part before a machine breaks. It can also save time on dull jobs, such as sorting thousands of messages. These are real benefits, but they come with a rule: AI should assist people, not replace their judgement. A doctor, teacher or engineer still checks the result and is responsible for the decision. A benefit is only a benefit if the tool works well for the people who use it.
Area
How AI can help
Who still checks?
health
marks unusual places on a scan
the doctor
accessibility
captions and reading aloud
the user, and the maker who tests it
farming
spots a sick plant in a photo
the farmer
Worked examples
Captions
ā¦see you at lunch with Aunt Emmy, Uncle Danā¦
Elif
I will write the names in the chat.
Elifās grandmother has poor hearing. Captions on a family video call let her follow the talk. The captions miss a few names, so Elif sends the names in writing.
Scan takenāProgram marks unusual placesāDoctor checks the scanāDoctor decides
A clinic tries a program that marks possible problems on scans. The doctor looks at every scan, and the program just sets the order.
Without AI
With AI
walk every field each week
camera warns about one field
treat the whole farm
treat the part that needs it
A farm camera finds yellow leaves early, so the farmer treats one field instead of the whole farm. That saves time, water and money.
Class activity
Match and weigh (groups of three). Make cards for six needs, such as āa pupil who is blind wants to read a noticeā, āa pupil who has just moved here is learning the languageā, āa clinic has too many scans to check quicklyā. On other cards write AI helpers: reading aloud, translation, marking scans, and so on. Match each need with a helper. Then, for every pair, write (1) one benefit, (2) one thing that could go wrong, and (3) who must check the result. Share the pair you found hardest and say why.
Practice
1
A school uses captions in assemblies. Name one group it helps and one thing the school should still do.
It helps pupils who are deaf or hard of hearing, and also pupils who are learning the language. The school should check the captions for mistakes in names and key words, and ask users if they help.
2
Why should a doctor still check a scan that a program has marked?
The program can miss problems or mark harmless places. The doctor can use the patientās history and is responsible. The program gives help, not a final decision.
3
Is this fair? āThe tool works for most people, so we do not need to test it with pupils who have different needs.ā
It works for most people, so we do not need more tests.
No. A tool can work well for many people and badly for some. Testing with different users finds problems early, and accessibility depends on it.
4
Give two benefits of AI that save people time and one task where you would still want a person to decide.
Time savers: sorting large piles of messages, spotting machine faults early. A person should decide something serious such as a medical treatment or a punishment, because it affects lives and needs judgement and responsibility.