Week 8 · Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world · 3 lessons
1
Questions that ask fairly
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9SW.05, 9TC.03
GoalWrite closed and open survey questions and spot leading questions.
New words
survey · a set of questions asked to many people to find out what they thinkclosed question · a question with fixed answers to choose from, such as yes/no or a scaleopen question · a question that people answer in their own wordsleading question · a question worded to push people towards one answer
Explanation
A survey asks the same questions to many people so that you can see patterns. The wording matters a great deal. A closed question gives fixed choices, such as yes or no, a list or a scale from 1 to 5. It is quick to answer and easy to count. An open question lets people write in their own words, which gives reasons and ideas but takes longer to read. A leading question pushes the answer: âDonât you agree that long assemblies are boring?â A fair version is âHow long should an assembly be?â Other common mistakes are asking two things in one question, using vague words such as âoftenâ, and giving choices that overlap or leave out an honest answer. Good questions are short, neutral and about one thing. Ask only what you need, and never ask for personal data.
Type
Example
Easy to count?
closed
Which poster do you like best, A, B or C?
yes
open
What would make our poster better?
no, you must read each answer
leading
Donât you agree posters are boring?
unfair, so do not use it
Worked examples
Question
Closed or open?
Which tip should go on the poster: A, B or C?
closed
What would you like to learn in the week?
open
How useful was last yearâs talk? 1 to 5
closed
Class 9B at the invented Linden School wants to plan a Safer Internet Week. Closed or open?
Leading
Fair
Wouldnât you say that the assembly is far too long?
How long should the assembly be: 10, 15 or 20 minutes?
A leading question and a fairer version.
Question
Problem
Do you like the poster and the talk? Yes / No
a person might like one but not the other
A double question hides two answers in one. What would a person who liked the poster but not the talk answer?
Class activity
Fix the questions (on paper, in pairs). Write six invented questions for a Linden School survey, with three mistakes planted: one leading question, one double question and one with overlapping choices (for example â0â5 minutes, 5â10 minutesâ). Swap papers. The partner finds each mistake, names it and rewrites the question fairly. Then each writes two new questions, one closed and one open, on the topic âwhat should Safer Internet Week include?â. Do not ask anyoneâs name, address or anything about their private life.
Practice
1
Is this closed or open: âWhat is the most useful thing you learned about posting?â
Open. People answer in their own words, so it gives ideas but takes longer to read.
2
Rewrite this fairly: âYou do want to stop being careless online, donât you?â
You do want to stop being careless online, donât you?
For example: âHow careful do you think pupils in our year are online: very careful, quite careful or not very careful?â The fair version is neutral and gives choices.
3
What is wrong with: âHow many hours do you spend online? 0â2 hours, 2â4 hours, 4â6 hoursâ?
How many hours online?
0â2
2â4
4â6
The choices overlap at 2 and 4, and nothing is offered for more than 6 hours. Use âunder 2â, â2 to under 4â, â4 to under 6â and â6 or moreâ. Also ask this only if it is really needed.
4
Split into two questions: âDo you enjoy the quiz and the film?â
Ask âDo you enjoy the quiz?â and then âDo you enjoy the film?â so each answer is clear.