Week 5 Ā· Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world Ā· 3 lessons
1
Who is behind the page?
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9DW.01
GoalUse the web address and the author to judge whether a source is likely to be reliable.
New words
source Ā· the person, group or page that information comes fromauthor Ā· the person or organisation that wrote somethingdomain name Ā· the main part of a web address that shows the owner, such as example.orgcredible Ā· able to be trusted because of evidence and honest purpose
Explanation
Anyone can put anything online, so you must judge who is speaking. Start with the address. Read the domain name from the right: in news.example.org the owner is example.org. A strange or oddly spelled address, or a long address full of extra words, is a warning, not proof. Then look for the author: a named person or organisation that knows the topic, and a way to contact them. A page with no author, or with a name that cannot be checked, is harder to trust, so treat its claims with doubt. Ask why the page exists: to inform, to sell, to persuade or to amuse. A lock symbol near the address shows only a private connection, not an honest page.
Worked examples
Page A
Page B
Address
www.example.org/hospital/sleep
www.sleep-miracle.example.net/!!
Author
Dr Maria Lopez, childrenās doctor
no name
Contact
phone and email shown
none
Purpose
inform
sell pills
Two invented pages about children and sleep. Page A comes from a named childrenās hospital, Page B from nobody.
A look-alike address. The owner is the last part before the path, which here is example.net.
An unsigned post, with a name that cannot be checked.
Class activity
Source detective (on paper). Invent three pages about a fictional topic: āa new school-lunch bread that makes children tallerā. Page 1 is from a named university, Page 2 from an anonymous blog, Page 3 from a bread company. Draw the address bar and the top of each page with an author line. Swap with a partner. Fill in a table with columns Address, Author, Purpose and write a ranking from most to least reliable, with ābecauseā sentences. Say what extra checks you would do. Do not visit real addresses.
Practice
1
Read the domain name from the right. Who owns each page? (a) shop.example.com (b) www.example.org.save-now.example.net/offer
Address
Owner
(a) shop.example.com
?
(b) www.example.org.save-now.example.net/offer
?
(a) example.com. (b) example.net ā the words example.org and save-now are only the beginning of a long host name. The second is a warning sign.
2
A page says āwritten by an expertā but gives no name. Is this enough? What do you ask for?
No. Ask for a named author and how to check that they know the topic, e.g. a school, a hospital or a book. āAn expertā without a name cannot be checked.
3
A page about a medicine is written by the company that sells it. Is it useless? Explain.
Not useless, but it has a purpose: to sell. It may leave out risks. Check with an independent source such as a doctor, a pharmacist or a health organisation.
4
Give two clues in a web address that make you more careful.
Misspellings, extra words or numbers, a long address with several names, or a link from an unknown message. Any two are correct. These are warnings, not proof.