Evolution of cells
According to palaeontological data, the oldest prokaryotic cells appeared about 3.5 billion years ago; eukaryotes are thought to have arisen later, about 1.5–2 billion years ago. By the symbiosis (endosymbiosis) hypothesis, mitochondria came from aerobic prokaryotes and chloroplasts from photosynthesising prokaryotes: they entered a larger host cell and moved to a mutually beneficial life together. Evidence: they have their own circular DNA, RNA and ribosomes, they multiply by division, and they have double membranes. By the invagination hypothesis, the nuclear envelope, endoplasmic reticulum and other membrane structures formed from the outer membrane folding inward; in the multi-genome hypothesis the eukaryotic genome is explained by a prokaryotic genome splitting into parts. In current science the symbiosis hypothesis is widely accepted for mitochondria and plastids, while the origin of the nucleus and other structures is still being studied. Since about 2015, findings on the closeness of archaea (the Asgard group) to eukaryotes have added new evidence to this research.
Nobody saw the events of two billion years ago, so this topic gives no everyday tool; it trains how to judge a claim. A scientist asks what evidence supports an idea and what would count against it. The same skill helps with a rumour or an advertisement.
An investigator compares pieces of evidence, a journalist checks a source, and a scientist designs a test for a hypothesis.
Next time you hear a surprising claim, write two questions: what is the evidence, and who could check it?
“Hypothesis court”. Three groups defend three hypotheses (symbiosis, invagination, multi-genome) while the rest ask questions. At the end the class decides which hypothesis is backed by good evidence for which organelle.