AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Contents · Geometry

Proof by contradiction. Practice

Lessons 16–17 · 2 lessons · Geometry Grade 7, corrected and expanded 3rd edition. Yangiyo‘l Poligraf Servis, Tashkent, 2017 (approved by the Ministry of Public Education)
16

Proof by contradiction

Textbook: pp. 40–41
GoalUnderstand proof by contradiction.
New words
assume the opposite · teskarisini faraz qilishcontradiction · ziddiyatmethod of proof · isbot usulinon-intersection · kesishmaslik
Explanation

In proof by contradiction we accept the hypothesis of the theorem and assume the conclusion is false. By logical steps we then reach a result that contradicts a known axiom or theorem. The contradiction shows the assumption was wrong, so the conclusion is true. Three things matter: write the opposite of the statement correctly; draw correct conclusions from the assumption; arrive at a result contradicting a known property. Theorem: two lines perpendicular to the same line do not intersect. In the proof we assume they intersect, which leads to two lines passing through two points, contradicting the axiom.

cabAB
💡 Where will I use this?
In real life

A pupil says: “I was in the library all afternoon, and at 4 o’clock I was at home.” If we assume both are true, then at 4 o’clock the pupil was in two places, which is impossible. So the assumption fails: the two statements cannot both be true. Assuming something and reaching an impossible result is proof by contradiction.

Who uses it

An investigator finds statements that do not fit together, a mathematician proves by assuming the opposite, and a programmer locates a bug through a logical conflict.

Try it today

Think of a claim, write its opposite and check whether the opposite contradicts a known fact.

Worked examples
Claim: two different lines cannot have two common points. Assume A and B are common; then two lines pass through A and B, contradicting the axiom. So the claim is true.
Claim: a segment has only one midpoint. Assume C ≠ D are midpoints. Then AC = AD = AB : 2, but on a ray only one segment of a given length can be laid off, so C = D. Contradiction.
Class activity

“Find the contradiction”: in pairs, pupils assume the opposite of a simple statement and find the contradiction.

Practice
1
What is the opposite of “a segment has one midpoint”?
2
In proof by contradiction, what does the contradiction show?
3
In a proof by contradiction two lines ended up with two common points. By the axiom, how many lines pass through two points?
4
Why is “two lines through two points” a contradiction?
Story of the Week · The Khwarizmi WayAn evening watch for crayfishClose the week: all of this week’s subjects in one storyRead →