☰ Contents · History of world religions

Religion, cinema and literature

Lessons 20 · 1 lessons · Z. Islomov, D. Rahimjonov, J. Najmiddinov, N. Ismatova. History of world religions, Grade 11, 1st edition. Yangiyul Poligraph Service, Tashkent, 2018
20

Religion, cinema and literature

Textbook: pp. 90–95
GoalAnalyse the role of cinema and fiction in forming religion, values and worldview; show a critical and impartial approach to works on religious themes; set out principles for choosing suitable content for children.
New words
cinematography · kinematografiyaideological immunity · mafkuraviy immunitetmass culture · ommaviy madaniyatcritical thinking · tanqidiy fikrlash
Explanation

Because cinema combines text, image and sound, it conveys information quickly and with strong effect; according to the textbook, besides informing it also educates and forms worldview and attitudes. Religious themes have been present in film and literature since long ago: examples from literature are Dante’s “Divine Comedy” (early 14th century), Mir Alisher Navoi’s Sufi allegorical poem “Lison ut-tayr” (around 1499), Jalaluddin Rumi’s “Masnavi” and John Milton’s “Paradise Lost” (1667); from cinema, films such as “Gandhi” (1982) or “Ben-Hur” (1959). The textbook stresses that some films and cartoons may contain violence, frightening scenes or ideas that do not match national values, and says parents’ attention is needed in choosing content for children; for this purpose Uzbekistan has a law on protecting children from information harmful to their healthy development (2017) and age-category labels. “Ideological immunity” here means the ability to assess critically what one sees and reads and not to give in to manipulation. When assessing a film or book on a religious theme, a scholar of religion analyses separately the accuracy of facts, the mass effect and the authors’ aims, but avoids discriminatory generalisations about any religion and its followers. It is also recalled as a historical fact that in the Soviet period literature and cinema were subordinated to state policy and atheistic propaganda was conducted.

Worked examples
Questions for film analysis: Which historical event does the story rest on? How closely do events match reality? From whose viewpoint is the film told? How can one tell whether there is a stereotype about some religion?
In Navoi’s poem “Lison ut-tayr” birds set out to seek the Simurgh; this is a Sufi allegorical tale linked with Farid ud-Din Attar’s “Mantiq ut-tayr”, and a scholar of religion studies it both as a religious and a literary source.
Class activity

Analysis: choose one film or book you know and write a brief analysis using the four questions above; show the process of analysis rather than only your own opinion of the work.

Practice
1
Why does cinema have a strong influence on forming ideas about religion and values?
2
What does “ideological immunity” mean?
3
Name two literary works on religious themes and their authors.
4
Why are the accuracy of facts and the author’s aim checked separately when assessing a film on a religious theme?