The logical structure of planimetry
“Geometry” is Greek for “earth measurement”; planimetry studies figures in a plane and stereometry figures in space. Geometry is built axiomatically: first basic figures such as the point and the line are accepted without definition, then their basic properties — the axioms — are accepted without proof, and all other figures are defined and their properties are proved as theorems. The axioms of planimetry fall into five groups: incidence, order, measurement, placing equal figures, and the parallel axiom. A theorem has a hypothesis (what is given) and a conclusion (what must be proved); a proof may use only axioms and previously proved theorems, even an “obvious” but unproved fact is not allowed. Euclid (around the beginning of the 3rd century BC) set out geometry in his Elements in 13 books with five postulates; the fifth postulate (about parallel lines) looked more complicated than the others, so for centuries people tried to prove it, among them Omar Khayyam. N. I. Lobachevsky (1792–1856) showed that it does not depend on the other axioms and created non-Euclidean geometry (where the angle sum of a triangle is less than 180°); Ya. Bolyai and K. Gauss contributed to this too.
Most jobs do not involve writing geometry proofs; this lesson trains something else: telling apart what is given from what must be shown, and justifying every step instead of trusting that it is obvious. The same habit helps when you read the rules of a game, a contract or the specification of a program.
Lawyers derive a conclusion step by step from the articles of a law, programmers write and check a precise specification, and scientists do not accept a claim until it is proved.
Pick a game or a school rule. Write what the rule itself states, then one consequence that follows from it, and check that the consequence needs no extra assumption that the rule does not state.
“Axiom or theorem?” game: the teacher reads geometric statements; students raise a hand and answer “axiom”, “theorem” or “definition” and explain why.