AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
Story of the WeekGrade 10 · Week 14

The four-rope pulley advert

🎯 Mission: “A four-rope pulley saves 75% of your effort and energy” — is the advert telling the truth?

Monday

AnvarOn the notice board there’s an advert: «Четыре верёвки — тяжесть в четыре раза меньше! Поднимает до пяти мешков. Экономит 75% энергии!»
ZarinaIn Russian : after «четыре» the noun is in the genitive singular («четыре верёвки»), but after «пять» it is genitive plural («пять мешков»).
Jasur«Три мешка», but «шесть мешков». The language is correct — now we check the content.
MalikaThe claim has two parts: the force is four times smaller, and 75% of the energy is saved. We’ll check each part separately.
Let’s build a model first and measure the force.
Russian language

Lock 1: The advert on the notice board

Your turn: Which phrase is correct?

ZarinaThere is an Uzbek version too: “A device that will change your life!” The form belongs to an elevated written style; in plain speech we say “will change”.
AnvarThe present-tense forms differ too: -yapti is for conversation, -moqda for newspapers and written texts, -yotir mostly for poetry.
JasurSo these set the tone: the advert tries to impress with grand words, not with proof.
Style is not proof — only a reason for caution. On to the numbers.
Uzbek language

Lock 2: The advert’s style

Your turn: Which present-tense form fits conversational style: “Bugun nima qilyapsan?”

Tuesday

AnvarThe model: a 2 kg load (about 20 N) and a four-rope pulley. We pull with a spring scale.
ZarinaFrom physics: when the load is shared by n ropes, ideally F = P/n. 20 : 4 = 5 N. The scale showed about 6 N.
JasurSo the force really is much smaller — about 3 times (4 times ideally). The first part of the advert is mostly right.
MalikaOnly made it 6 N rather than 5 N. In every real mechanism the efficiency is below 100%.
First key: the reduction in force is confirmed. About energy we know nothing yet.
Physics

Lock 3: The model and the spring scale

Your turn: In an ideal pulley system with n ropes, what is the effort?

🔑 Key: In the model a 2 kg load (≈20 N) was lifted by a four-rope pulley with ≈6 N: about 3 times less force, 4 times in the ideal case (5 N).

AnvarI lift the load 0.5 m. The pulled end moves 4 · 0.5 = 2 m with four ropes.
ZarinaForce ÷ 4, distance × 4: force × distance — the work — stays the same, so no gain in work.
JasurThe rope drum is a : r = 3 cm, h = 10 cm. Lateral surface S = 2πrh = 2π · 3 · 10 = 60π ≈ 188 cm².
MalikaThe load is a cone-shaped sandbag: r = 3 cm, generator l = 5 cm; its lateral surface is πrl = π · 3 · 5 = 15π ≈ 47 cm².
The most important is the second key: the distance becomes four times longer, so “saves 75% of the energy” is in doubt.
Mathematics

Lock 4: Rope length

Your turn: A load is lifted 1.2 m. How far does the pulled end of a four-rope pulley move?

🔑 Key: To lift the load 0.5 m you must pull the rope 4 · 0.5 = 2 m: force ÷ 4, distance × 4 — no work is saved.

Wednesday

MalikaWe entered the results in Access: a Trials table with five attempts: 6.0; 6.5; 6.0; 6.5; 6.0 N.
AnvarIn Datasheet view the Σ Totals button gives: Sum = 31, Average = 6.2, Count = 5. That row only displays; it doesn’t change the records.
ZarinaLinking tables: Claims is the “one” side, Evidence the “many” side; ClaimID is the . Referential Integrity forbids a link to a claim that doesn’t exist.
JasurThe average is 6.2 N, not the ideal 5 N. Load 0.5 m, pulled end 2 m: work in is 6.2 · 2 = 12.4 J, work out is 20 · 0.5 = 10 J. Efficiency ≈ 81%.
Third key: no energy is saved — because of friction, more is spent.
Computing

Lock 5: The table and the average

Your turn: Which tool shows the average of a table column in Access?

🔑 Key: Average 6.2 N; work in 6.2 · 2 = 12.4 J, useful work 20 · 0.5 = 10 J: efficiency ≈ 81%, no energy is saved.

ZarinaTest week: tasks are urgent or important. Let’s plan the day in advance and divide tasks into small steps.
AnvarYou should switch off phone notifications — they are a distraction! And you ought to do one thing at a time.
MalikaCalendar entry: 10 December, 14:00, Check the advert. Each entry needs a date, a time and a short task name.
JasurMake a list! — that’s an imperative. You should make a list — that’s a modal. Both give advice.
English

Lock 6: Planning

Your turn: What should every calendar entry include?

ZarinaIn geography there are two methods of : the qualitative one uses words (“favourable”), the quantitative one uses numbers, for example the sum of active temperatures.
AnvarIn the advert “very easy” and “excellent” are qualitative words. There are only two numbers: “4 times” and “75%”. We measured the first, not the second.
MalikaThe advert also says: “welded hook”. From chemistry: acetylene burned in oxygen gives a flame of about 3000 °C and is used for welding and cutting metals.
JasurAcetylene is an : it has a triple bond and the formula C₂H₂. Calcium carbide + water: CaC₂ + 2H₂O → C₂H₂↑ + Ca(OH)₂. That statement is true, but says nothing about the energy claim.
The advert has true statements too — that is why the verdict isn’t simply “false”. Let’s list them separately.
Geography (Applied geography)Chemistry (Organic chemistry)

Lock 7: Quality or quantity?

Your turn: Which method relies on numbers?

🔑 Key: The advert has only two numbers: “4 times” (mostly confirmed) and “75%” (refuted); the rest is words like “very easy”.

Thursday

ZarinaIn literature: the “Boburnoma” is a memoir-chronicle; according to the textbook it covers about 50 years, but the events of 1508–1520, 1525 and 1530 are not reflected in it.
AnvarThe textbook stresses the author’s and his precise, concise telling. A good source also shows what it does not cover.
JasurThe advert, though, says nothing about friction, the longer distance or how it was tested.
MalikaThe same in history: on 4 May 1919 students demonstrated in Beijing — that date is recorded in documents. Or the Indian National Congress, which supported . Documents are evidence, not popularity.
The advert says “10,000 happy customers”, but gives no document. Popularity isn’t proof.
LiteratureWorld history

Lock 8: What the source does not say

Your turn: Which is a sign of a reliable source?

AzizMy tomato seedling went pale in the cupboard. Will its seeds give pale plants too?
ZarinaNo: that is a — the genotype doesn’t change, the trait changes with the environment within the norm of reaction, and it isn’t inherited. A mutation is a change of the genetic material.
AnvarHuman genetics has checking methods too: the and the : identical twins are genetically the same, so differences come from the environment.
MalikaThe twin method is like fact-checking: we change one thing and keep the rest. Our model did that too: only the number of ropes changed.
The answer, Aziz: the seedling went pale in the cupboard because of the environment. Its seeds will be ordinary.
Biology

Lock 9: Variation

Your turn: Is the trait of a seedling that went pale in the dark inherited?

Friday

MalikaWe list the advert’s two parts: “force 4 times smaller” — true in the ideal case (5 N), in reality ≈6 N, about 3 times. “75% of energy saved” — false.
AnvarNo work is saved: the distance gets 4 times longer. Because of friction the work in is 12.4 J and the useful work 10 J.
ZarinaThe qualitative words and style raised suspicion, but the measurements decide the verdict.
JasurVerdict: MISLEADING. A pulley reduces the force but does not save energy. And when lifting loads with adults we keep to safety rules.
Agreed. Let’s write the report.
Physics

Lock 10: The verdict

Your turn: Which keys mainly decided the verdict?

A whole week in one story!

This story brought together 11 subjects.

MathematicsUzbek languageEnglishComputingLiteratureBiologyPhysicsGeography (Applied geography)World historyChemistry (Organic chemistry)Russian language

0 / 13 stars

Team report

A pulley saves force, not energy — MISLEADING

Claim: “A four-rope pulley saves 75% of your effort and energy.” Verdict: MISLEADING. In the model a 20 N load was lifted with ≈6 N (ideal 5 N): the force really is much smaller (about 3 times). But the rope must be pulled 4 times farther and, with friction, 12.4 J goes in for 10 J out — no energy is saved. What to do: compare the word “saves” with numbers and a test.

— 10-B team

Keys found

  1. In the model a 2 kg load (≈20 N) was lifted by a four-rope pulley with ≈6 N: about 3 times less force, 4 times in the ideal case (5 N).
  2. To lift the load 0.5 m you must pull the rope 4 · 0.5 = 2 m: force ÷ 4, distance × 4 — no work is saved.
  3. Average 6.2 N; work in 6.2 · 2 = 12.4 J, useful work 20 · 0.5 = 10 J: efficiency ≈ 81%, no energy is saved.
  4. The advert has only two numbers: “4 times” (mostly confirmed) and “75%” (refuted); the rest is words like “very easy”.

Star questions

  1. What increases when a pulley system reduces the force?

  2. Which part of the advert was confirmed?

  3. Think: with a six-rope pulley, a load rises 0.5 m. How far does the pulled end move?

Lessons in this story