Week 6 Ā· Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world Ā· 3 lessons
2
Who might look later?
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9SW.05
GoalWeigh up why schools, clubs and employers may look at public posts, and what they cannot see.
New words
reputation Ā· what other people think of you from what they know about youpublic Ā· visible to anyone, not only to friendscontext Ā· the facts around a post that explain what it meantapplicant Ā· a person who asks for a place or a job
Explanation
Some schools, clubs and employers look at what is public about an applicant when they decide who gets a place. Not all of them do, and the rules differ from country to country. Some people say this is unfair, because a joke from years ago says little about a grown person. Others say that public words are public, and that they show judgement. Both views have a point. The big problem is context: a joke between friends can look unkind to a stranger who does not know the friends. They usually see only what is public, not your private messages or your passive footprint. Good news also travels: a public thank-you note, a prize or a helpful guide can speak well for you. So you do not need a perfect record, but you should be able to explain every public post.
Who might look
What they may be asking
a youth orchestra
Is this person reliable and kind to others?
a sports club
Will this person work well in a team?
a future employer
Does this person use good judgement?
Worked examples
Faridās invented public page, as an orchestra panel might see it. Not everything is clear without context.
Candidate
Public comment
What a stranger may think
Imani
Thank you to everyone who came to our concert!
kind, grateful
Tariq
That conductor is useless, lol
rude, though he may have been joking
Two public comments by two invented candidates. A stranger reads them with no context.
For looking
Against looking
shows how a person treats others
a joke can be misread
public means anyone may see it
a person can change and grow up
helps clubs keep people safe
not everyone has a fair chance to be seen
Arguments for and against looking at public posts.
Class activity
Selection panel (role-play on paper, three people). The invented Riverside Youth Orchestra has one place. Two players write a short public āpageā for an invented candidate: three posts each, one of them positive, one neutral and one that could be misread. The third player is the panel and writes: what I notice, what I cannot know, and what I would ask the candidate. Swap roles. Then all three agree on a fair rule for panels, such as āask the candidate to explain before judgingā, and on one rule for candidates. Answers will vary; look for reasons that use the word ābecauseā. Use only invented people.
Practice
1
Give one reason why a club might look at public posts, and one reason why this might be unfair.
For: it may show how a person treats others. Unfair: a joke can be misread without context, or a person may have changed. Any sensible pair of reasons is correct.
2
Elenaās public post from two years ago says āMaths club is boring!ā She now wants to join the school robotics club. What can she do?
Elena (two years ago): Maths club is boring!
She can ask a trusted adult to help her delete it if the account is hers, and be ready to explain that she has changed. One old post is not the end of the world.
3
Which is more likely to be seen by a stranger: a private message to a friend, or a public thank-you post? Explain.
Item
Who can see it
private message
?
public thank-you post
?
The public post. Anyone can read it. A private message is seen only by the people in it, unless one of them shares it.
4
Write one sentence that would help a stranger understand a joke post.
For example: āThis was a joke between team-mates after we lost 10ā0.ā A short explanation adds context. Any clear sentence is correct.