Week 3 · Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world · 3 lessons
3
Bubbles and echoes
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9SW.02
GoalDefine a filter bubble and an echo chamber, tell them apart and describe ways to widen what you see.
New words
filter bubble · what you see is narrowed by algorithms using your past behaviourecho chamber · a place where you mostly meet views like your own, through peopleâs choices and algorithmsalgorithm · steps a computer follows to decide, for example, what to show firstviewpoint · the way a person looks at a question
Explanation
Imagine a feed that learns you like cats. The next day there are more cat videos, and fewer of everything else. That is a filter bubble: an algorithm uses your past clicks to narrow what you see. An echo chamber is a little different. You follow friends and groups who think like you, and the algorithm shows you more of them. You hear your own opinion repeated back. Both can make the world look smaller or more one-sided than it is, and you may not notice. They are not always bad: a cat fan enjoys cat videos. The problem appears with news and ideas. A good habit is to look for different sources, ask âwhat is missing?â, and talk to people with other views.
Filter bubble
Echo chamber
Who narrows it?
an algorithm using my past clicks
who I follow and listen to (and the algorithm)
Result
I see too little that is different
I hear my own view repeated
Worked examples
Nodira watches skate videosâThe algorithm shows more skate videosâFewer other topics reach her feed
A filter bubble in three steps. An invented pupil, Nodira, clicks on one kind of video.
Omar
The new bus timetable is terrible.
Lola
Totally, awful!
Tom
Yes! Everyone agrees.
An echo chamber. Everyone in the group agrees, so nobody hears another view.
Habit
How it helps
read a source you donât usually visit
shows another side
follow someone who disagrees politely
you meet other ideas
search the topic with different words
gets different results
Widening your view. Ana chooses to look beyond her feed.
Class activity
Bubble map (on paper). Draw a circle for âWhat my feed showsâ and a larger circle around it for âWhat existsâ. Write five topics inside the small circle (invented, e.g. football, cooking, a game) and five outside it (e.g. local news, a different sport, science, art, other languages). Then write three actions you could take to move one topic from outside into your circle (ask a librarian, talk to a friend, read a different kind of source). Compare with a partner and explain whether your small circle came from you or from an algorithm.
Practice
1
Is it a filter bubble or an echo chamber? (a) A video app shows only cooking clips because of past clicks. (b) A pupil follows only people who share her opinion about a school rule.
(a) A filter bubble: an algorithm chooses from past behaviour. (b) An echo chamber: the pupilâs own choice of who to follow, which an app may strengthen.
2
Why can a filter bubble be a problem when you are researching a topic for school?
You may see only one side or the most popular view, so your research is one-sided. A good researcher looks at several kinds of sources.
3
Write two things you could do to leave a bubble.
Examples: search with different words, read a library book, ask a teacher for sources, listen politely to a friend with another view, follow a variety of creators. Any two are correct.
4
Is a filter bubble always harmful? Give a reason for and against.
For
Against
?
?
No. It can help you find what you enjoy faster (for). But it can hide other ideas or facts (against). Answers will vary â look for balance.