Who is harmed?
Piracy can seem harmless because nobody sees the loss. In fact, many people are affected. The makers lose payment and recognition, and so do their families. Small studios and independent musicians depend on every sale to pay for the next work, so they may stop creating. Other workers lose too, such as editors, actors, sound engineers and shop staff. Future audiences lose the works that were never made. Some people say, āI would not have bought it anyway.ā But taking something you would not buy still gives the maker nothing, and it still breaks the law in most countries. Others say piracy helps when people cannot afford things. That is a real problem, and it is part of the digital divide, but there are legal ways to get work cheaply or free, such as libraries and free releases. Weigh each argument by asking who gains, who loses and whether there is a fair alternative.
| Argument for copying | Reply |
|---|---|
| āI would not have bought it anyway.ā | The maker still gets nothing; you used the work. |
| āIt promotes the maker.ā | Makers can choose to share free; it should be their choice. |
| āI cannot afford it.ā | Libraries and free releases are legal; the need is real, but the solution is not taking. |
It is only one film. Nobody will notice.
The makers will notice if enough people do the same. And I would rather borrow it from the library.
Debate on paper (groups of four). The statement is: āCopying one film without permission does no harm.ā Two members prepare the case for and two the case against. Each side writes three reasons on separate strips, then reads them one at a time. After each reason the other side writes a reply on a strip. Then vote silently on whether the statement is true, giving one reason on the back of your vote. Finally, write one sentence on which reason you found most convincing, even if it was from the side you disagreed with. Do not search for, name or describe any places to find unauthorised copies.
Some families cannot pay, so copying helps them.
Copying their songs is free advertising for the band.