AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page Ā· students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Year plan · Digital Literacy

Who pays for play

Week 23 Ā· Unit 9.3: That’s entertainment Ā· 3 lessons
3

Is it fair?

Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.3, objectives 9SW.03
GoalWeigh payment models for fairness, using reasons about makers, players and the person who actually pays.
New words
fair Ā· treating people reasonably and openlytransparent Ā· clear about what you pay and what you getpersonal data Ā· facts about a person, sometimes collected as a kind of paymentincome Ā· money a business or person earns
Explanation

To judge whether a payment model is fair, look from three sides. The makers need income, or the game could not exist, and creative work deserves a reward. Players need to know what they are paying for and not be tricked or pressed into spending. The person who pays may be a parent or carer, who needs control of the bills. A fair model is transparent: the price is clear before you commit, the odds of any random reward are shown and you can set a limit. A less fair model hides costs, works on feelings of fear of missing out or gives paying players a big advantage. Adverts and data are also a kind of payment, so check what is collected. When you give your opinion, state your reason and name one advantage of the model you did not choose.

ViewpointNeedsWarning sign
makersincome to keep making gamesnone; this need is real
playersclear price, fair playhidden costs, pressure
the person payingcontrol and limitspayments that are hard to stop
Worked examples
ExtraEarn by playingBuy
new field10 hoursone clear price
decorationsfinish a questone clear price
A fairer design in an invented farming game. Extras can be earned or bought, and the price is shown.
Imran

I suggest one clear price for the club game, because everyone can see the cost first. The makers need income to keep working.

A club leader’s recommendation. It gives a reason and shows respect for the makers.
Banner

Last chance! Buy now or lose your reward forever!

A problem design. Notice the two warning signs.
Class activity

Advice sheet (individual, paper). Write a half-page guide for a younger brother or sister called ā€˜Three questions before a game asks for money’. Choose your three questions, give a reason for each and add one sentence saying why makers must be paid. Before writing, plan three boxes: what players pay, what they get, who pays. After writing, swap with a partner who ticks the success list: 1. three clear questions; 2. a reason for each; 3. one fair word about the makers; 4. kind, calm wording; 5. nothing in the guide asks anyone to spend money on a real product.

Practice
1
Which model is most open about cost: a one-off price, a random pack or a hidden monthly charge? Explain.
ModelDo you know the full cost in advance?
one-off price?
random pack?
hidden monthly charge?
2
Yuki’s parents pay for a family subscription. Name two things the parents should check.
3
Choose the fairer idea and explain: (a) players who pay can skip every level; (b) players can earn rewards by playing, and extras only change the look.
A

Pay and skip every level!

B

Earn rewards by playing. Paying only changes the look of your character.

4
Write two sentences for and two against: ā€˜Makers should be free to charge for extras.’