AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Year plan · Digital Literacy

Screens, creators, claims

Week 21 · Unit 9.3: That’s entertainment · 3 lessons
3

Trust the claim?

Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.3, objectives 9DW.03, 9DW.05, 9DW.01
GoalJudge an online creator’s claim using evidence and other sources, and weigh up statements about video sharing.
New words
claim · something a person says is trueevidence · facts, measurements or sources that support a claimconflict of interest · when someone gains if you believe or buyeditorial control · editors checking and deciding what is published
Explanation

Before you believe a creator, ask who is speaking and what they gain. A conflict of interest exists when someone profits if you believe them or buy something. Next look for evidence, such as a measurement, a named expert or a test anyone could repeat. A smiling face, a large number of followers and a confident voice are not evidence. Then check two other independent sources, for example a library book or a trained professional. Broadcast television and newspapers usually have editors who check facts before publishing, which is called editorial control. On video-sharing sites most videos go online first, so more of the checking is left to you. That does not make every creator unreliable. Many explain science, repairs or languages very well, and the best show their sources.

QuestionStronger signWeaker sign
Who is speaking?named, with relevant traininganonymous or no link to the subject
What do they gain?nothing, or they say sopaid, or selling something
What is the evidence?tests, data, named sources‘trust me’, big promises
Do others agree?independent sources matchonly fans repeat it
Worked examples
Jonas

My snack bar gives you energy all day. Four million people watched this video.

A claim that rests on popularity. Notice that the number of views does not show the snack bar works.
SourceWhat it saysIndependent of the seller?
Seller’s videodoubles tomato cropno
Garden-centre leafletsmall increase in some soilsyes
Gardening club trialno clear changeyes
Checking a claim against other sources (invented). The claim is supported only when independent sources agree.
Aisha Verma@aisha_repairsI fix things and show my mistakes. Sourcesare in every description.64videos2300followersTopicsrepairs, tools
A creator who shows their working. The profile points to evidence a viewer can check.
Class activity

Claim court (groups of three, paper). A parent or teacher reads three invented claims: (1) ‘This bracelet makes you sleep better’ from a seller’s video; (2) ‘Bridges are stronger when built with triangles’ from an engineer’s course page; (3) ‘Everyone who uses this app passes exams’ from a creator with a discount code. For each claim fill in a grid with four columns: who is speaking, what they gain, what evidence is given, and what you would check next. Each group gives a verdict (believe, believe with care, do not believe yet) and one sentence of reasons. Compare verdicts with another group and note any difference.

Practice
1
A creator says the following. Give two reasons to be careful.
Creator

This study app doubles your marks! Use my code SMART for a discount.

2
Rank these from most to least reliable for a claim about vitamin pills, and give a reason: (a) the creator who sells them; (b) a pharmacist’s leaflet; (c) a friend’s comment; (d) a national health agency’s page.
SourceRank
a creator who sells them?
pharmacist’s leaflet?
friend’s comment?
national health agency’s page?
3
A guitar creator’s fans plan a meet-up at a school hall. Name two benefits and one safety rule.
4
Describe three steps for checking the claim ‘Cold showers cure tiredness’.