AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page Ā· students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Year plan · Digital Literacy

Hype or evidence?

Week 18 Ā· Unit 9.2: My children’s digital world Ā· 3 lessons
2

Spot the hype

Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.2, objectives 9DW.06, 9TC.04, 9DW.01
GoalJudge predictions about new technology by their evidence, their source and who gains.
New words
hype Ā· exaggerated excitement used to get attention or salestrack record Ā· how right or wrong someone’s earlier predictions wereconflict of interest Ā· a situation where someone gains from you believing a claimexpert Ā· a person with proven knowledge of a subject
Explanation

Hype makes a new technology sound sure and close, so it helps to have a checklist. Ask who is speaking and what they gain. A company that sells the product has a reason to sound certain. Ask what the evidence is: a test with numbers, or only a polished video? Look for honest limits. Reliable forecasts mention cost, safety, rules and skills that could slow things down. Check the speaker’s track record, and whether the expert knows this field. Compare the claim with at least two independent sources. Also look at the timing: ā€˜next year’ is a bolder claim than ā€˜within twenty years’. Some bold predictions do come true. The checklist does not prove a claim false; it tells you how much to trust it today.

QuestionHype often showsBetter sign
Who gains?seller promoting the productindependent researcher
Evidence?one demo or videotests with numbers
Limits?none mentionedcosts and risks named
Words?definitely, everyone, nevercould, likely, if
Worked examples
RoadFuture_Co3 h agoOur flying taxis will replace allbuses in two years. Guaranteed!concept picture120058
A company post about a new product. It claims a lot and shows little.
Company postIndependent study
Who gains?sells taxisnone
Evidence?a concept picture42 test flights
Limits named?nonoise, cost, rules
Timingtwo yearssome cities in 15 years, if rules allow
Two reports about the same invented flying-taxi idea, compared with the checklist.
Mina

The company has no test data, and it sells taxis.

Mina

I will look for a study from someone who gains nothing.

A reader’s notes. Notice that the final line names a next step, not a verdict.
Class activity

Prediction court (groups of four, paper). Your teacher or group writes five prediction cards about invented technologies, such as home 3D printers, robot tutors or solar roads. Give each a score from 0 to 2 for each of four questions (who gains, evidence, limits, wording) and add up. Rank the cards from most to least believable. Take the lowest card and rewrite it as a balanced prediction using the best evidence you can imagine. Then each member says one question they would ask the person who made the claim. Keep a record of your scores in a table.

Practice
1
Rewrite the claim on the card into a balanced prediction.

Self-driving cars will end all accidents next year.

2
A video from a shoe company says its smart shoe will make you run twice as fast. Which three checklist questions would you ask?
SourceClaim
shoe company videorun twice as fast
3
Why is a prediction from a forecaster who has been wrong five times in six less trustworthy?
ForecasterPredictionsRight
R. Dunn61
4
Give one reason why a bold prediction can still be right.