Week 15 Ā· Unit 9.2: My childrenās digital world Ā· 3 lessons
2
Surprise or worry?
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.2, objectives 9DW.06, 9TC.02
GoalWeigh the benefits and risks of aggregated data, including targeted adverts, and describe what data protection rules try to do.
New words
targeted advert Ā· an advert chosen for you using data about your behaviour or interestsdata protection law Ā· rules that limit how organisations may collect, use and share personal dataidentity theft Ā· using someoneās personal details to pretend to be themopt out Ā· to choose not to take part, for example in tracking
Explanation
Aggregated data can help. A city can join traffic, weather and accident data to place warning signs. A health service can spot where a disease is spreading faster. It can also surprise or worry people. Advertisers can join what you search, where your phone has been and what you buy to guess your interests, so an advert may seem to āknowā something you never told anyone. Joined-up data is also a prize for criminals, who can use it for identity theft, and a wrong join can attach one personās record to another. Data protection laws, such as GDPR in the European Union, try to set limits: use data only for a clear purpose, collect no more than needed, keep it safe, say how long you keep it, and give people rights to see, correct and delete their data. The exact rules differ between countries.
Benefit
Risk
traffic and weather joined to place warning signs
a detailed picture of where people go
faster response to illness
identity theft if the data leaks
adverts that are less random
feeling watched; wrong guesses
Worked examples
Trail map searchesāPhone near a sports shopāCousinās walking postāWalking boots advert
Ana, 14, searched for trail maps on one device, her phone was near a sports shop, and her cousin posted about a walking trip. Later she sees an advert for walking boots. Each fragment was ordinary; joined together they suggest an interest.
Customer
Record
Sam Ortiz, Marsden
bought a ladder
Sam Ortiz, Marsden
asked about a loan
A wrong join. Two customers have the same name and the same town, so the system merges them. The result is wrong for both.
Principle
Plain meaning
purpose
a clear reason to collect
minimum
only what is needed
security
keep it safe
rights
see, correct, delete
What data protection rules try to do, in plain words.
Class activity
Rights card and risk ranking (groups of four). Part 1: your teacher gives you five invented joins about a pupil called Dara, such as ābus card + sports clubā, āshop app + search historyā and ālibrary list + school recordsā. For each join, write the new fact it could show. Then rank the joins from most to least worrying and give one reason for your top choice. Part 2: write a rights card for Dara in your own words: five things he may ask an organisation (for example, what do you hold about me? can you correct it? can you delete it?). Present one idea to the class and listen to one that is different from yours.
Practice
1
A family sees adverts for tents soon after one of them looked at camping pages on the shared tablet. A child is sure the tablet was listening. Give two other explanations.
Device
Used by
shared tablet
three family members
Joined data: the searches on the shared tablet, the places the devices have been and what the family bought can be linked to guess an interest. Another person on the same device may also have looked. A lucky guess is possible too. Do not assume that someone is listening.
2
What is identity theft and how can aggregated data make it easier?
Identity theft is using someoneās details to pretend to be them. Joined data can give a thief many details (name, address, birth date) in one place.
3
Match each rule to what it does: purpose, minimum, security, rights.
Rule
What it does
purpose
?
minimum
?
security
?
rights
?
Purpose: a clear reason to collect. Minimum: only what is needed. Security: keep it safe. Rights: see, correct and delete your data.
4
Do you think aggregated data is mostly good or mostly worrying? Give one reason for your view and one for the other side.
Answers will vary. Look for a reasoned view such as: mostly good because it plans traffic and health services, but worrying because it makes detailed profiles and can leak.