Week 14 Ā· Unit 9.2: My childrenās digital world Ā· 3 lessons
2
A city bus puzzle
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.2, objectives 9TC.04, 9DW.01, 9TC.03
GoalFollow an invented big data problem from the data sources to a checked solution, and judge how reliable the data is.
New words
data source Ā· where data comes fromanalysis Ā· studying data to find patterns and answersunintended effect Ā· a result nobody planned, good or badcross-check Ā· comparing with a second, independent source
Explanation
In the invented city of Rivertown, buses on Route 7 are often late. The transport office has three data sources: GPS positions from the buses, the times when travel cards are tapped, and notes about road works. On their own they tell little. Together, analysis shows that delays grow at the Bridge Street stop between 8 and 9 am, when road works narrow the road. That points to a solution: change the timetable for that hour and move the stop. Before they act, the team checks reliability. Who collected each set, when and how? Are there missing taps or sensor errors? Does a second source agree? Search skills help: an exact phrase, a file-type limit and a date filter can find the official road-works notice quickly. Solutions can have unintended effects, so the team also asks who might be affected.
Collect: GPS, taps, noticesāClean and checkāAnalyse patternsāDecide a solutionāWatch for side effects
Worked examples
The team compares average lateness for each hour. The bar chart shows the 8 am peak that points to the cause.
Source
Left stop
GPS
08:05
Card taps
08:20
Cross-checking. The GPS says a bus left at 8:05, but the cards show taps at 8:20. The team asks which is right before using either.
Finding the road-works notice with a narrow search: an exact phrase and a document type, then a date filter for the latest year.
Class activity
Solve the Route 7 puzzle (groups of three, on paper). Your teacher draws a small table of invented data: lateness at four stops for one week, plus a note āBridge Street lane closed 7ā10 amā. Draw a bar chart, find the worst stop and hour, and write a one-line solution. Then list three reliability checks (for example: Do two sources agree? Are any days missing?) and two unintended effects (for example: a shop loses passing customers if the stop moves; people without cards are missed in the counts). Compare your solutions and say which side effect worries you most.
Practice
1
Why does the team compare two independent sources before acting?
Source
Bus reached the depot
Driverās log
17:10
Depot screen
17:24
Two sources that disagree may mean an error in one of them. Agreement from two independent sources makes the finding more trustworthy.
2
Name one reason a card-based count might undercount passengers.
Some people pay cash or do not tap, children may travel free without a tap and cards can fail. The data may miss them.
3
Suggest one solution for the late bus and one unintended effect.
Solution: add a bus in the 8 am hour or use a short bus lane. Unintended effect: a shop near the old stop loses customers, or other traffic is slowed.
4
Write a search that finds a PDF on site example.org with the exact phrase ātimetable changeā from the last year. What parts of the search do what?
For example: ātimetable changeā site:example.org filetype:pdf, then use a date filter for the past year. Quotation marks keep the words together, site: limits the website, filetype: limits the type and the date filter keeps recent results.