Planning a solubility investigation; paper chromatography
Week 5 · Unit 2 · 2.3–2.4 · 3 lessons
3
Colours apart
Learner’s Book 8: Topics 2.3–2.4, pp. 47–61
GoalUse paper chromatography to separate dissolved colours and interpret a chromatogram.
New words
chromatography · a method that separates dissolved substances as a solvent moves through paperchromatogram · the paper with the separated colours on itsolvent front · the highest point the solvent reaches on the paperpure substance · a single substance, which makes one spot on a chromatogram
Explanation
Many colours are mixtures of dyes. Paper chromatography separates them. A spot of the colour is placed on a pencil line near the bottom of a strip of absorbent paper. The bottom of the paper stands in a shallow layer of solvent, which is water for water-soluble colours, with the spot above the water. The solvent moves up the paper, dissolves the dyes and carries them upwards. A dye that is more soluble in the solvent, and less strongly held by the paper, is carried further, so the dyes end up at different heights. The result is a chromatogram. The line is made with pencil because pencil is insoluble and does not run. Take the paper out before the solvent front reaches the top. A pure substance gives one spot; a mixture gives more than one spot. Spots at the same height in two samples are probably the same substance. Permanent marker ink is not soluble in water, so it needs a different solvent, which is for adults in a laboratory only.
Worked examples
Aisha’s chromatogram shows that pen B contains one dye and pen A contains two dyes. The blue dye travelled the shortest distance: it is the least soluble in water and the most strongly held by the paper.
Matching: a mystery drink’s colour makes spots at the same heights as dyes P and Q, so it probably contains both. This is evidence, but not proof, because other dyes could travel the same height.
pencil line and small spot→hang with the line above the water→water climbs and carries the dyes→take out and dry: chromatogram
The method: pencil line about 2 cm from the bottom, small spot, dry, add more, paper hangs from a pencil so only the bottom is in the water, and remove it before the water reaches the top.
Class activity
Chromatography with an adult, using only water. Cut a coffee filter paper into strips (an adult cuts). Draw a pencil line 2 cm from the bottom and put a dot of colour from a washable felt-tip pen or a coloured sweet (rub a wet cotton bud on the sweet) on the line. Pour 1 cm of water in a glass and hang the strip from a pencil laid across the top so the dot is above the water. Watch for ten minutes and take it out before the water reaches the top. Compare 3 or 4 colours. Which pens are pure? Which dye travelled furthest? Does one chromatogram prove which pen drew a mystery line? What else would make you more confident? Never use alcohol or nail polish remover; never use marker ink.
Practice
1
A black felt-tip pen gives a chromatogram with three coloured spots. Is the black ink a pure substance? Explain.
No. A pure substance gives only one spot. Three spots show that the black ink is a mixture of three dyes.
2
Look at the chromatogram. Which pen contains only one dye? Which two pens share a blue dye? How can you tell?
Pen E has only one dye. Pens D and F share a blue dye, because their blue spots are at the same height. (All three pens also contain the same yellow dye.)
3
On a chromatogram the solvent front is 8 cm above the start line. One dye spot is 6 cm up and another is 2 cm up. What fraction of the way to the front did each travel? Which dye is more soluble?
6 ÷ 8 = 0.75 and 2 ÷ 8 = 0.25. The dye at 6 cm travelled further, so it is the more soluble.
4
Why can water be used as the solvent for the dyes in coloured sweets, but not for permanent marker ink?
The dyes in sweets dissolve in water, so water carries them up the paper. Permanent marker ink does not dissolve in water, so it would stay on the line; a different solvent is needed, which is for adults in a laboratory only.