AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Year plan · Science

Planning a solubility investigation; paper chromatography

Week 5 · Unit 2 · 2.3–2.4 · 3 lessons
3

Colours apart

Learner’s Book 8: Topics 2.3–2.4, pp. 47–61
GoalUse paper chromatography to separate dissolved colours and interpret a chromatogram.
New words
chromatography · a method that separates dissolved substances as a solvent moves through paperchromatogram · the paper with the separated colours on itsolvent front · the highest point the solvent reaches on the paperpure substance · a single substance, which makes one spot on a chromatogram
Explanation

Many colours are mixtures of dyes. Paper chromatography separates them. A spot of the colour is placed on a pencil line near the bottom of a strip of absorbent paper. The bottom of the paper stands in a shallow layer of solvent, which is water for water-soluble colours, with the spot above the water. The solvent moves up the paper, dissolves the dyes and carries them upwards. A dye that is more soluble in the solvent, and less strongly held by the paper, is carried further, so the dyes end up at different heights. The result is a chromatogram. The line is made with pencil because pencil is insoluble and does not run. Take the paper out before the solvent front reaches the top. A pure substance gives one spot; a mixture gives more than one spot. Spots at the same height in two samples are probably the same substance. Permanent marker ink is not soluble in water, so it needs a different solvent, which is for adults in a laboratory only.

pen Apen Bpen Cstart linesolvent front
Worked examples
pen Apen Bstart linesolvent front
Aisha’s chromatogram shows that pen B contains one dye and pen A contains two dyes. The blue dye travelled the shortest distance: it is the least soluble in water and the most strongly held by the paper.
drinkdye Pdye Qdye Rstart linesolvent front
Matching: a mystery drink’s colour makes spots at the same heights as dyes P and Q, so it probably contains both. This is evidence, but not proof, because other dyes could travel the same height.
The method: pencil line about 2 cm from the bottom, small spot, dry, add more, paper hangs from a pencil so only the bottom is in the water, and remove it before the water reaches the top.
Class activity

Chromatography with an adult, using only water. Cut a coffee filter paper into strips (an adult cuts). Draw a pencil line 2 cm from the bottom and put a dot of colour from a washable felt-tip pen or a coloured sweet (rub a wet cotton bud on the sweet) on the line. Pour 1 cm of water in a glass and hang the strip from a pencil laid across the top so the dot is above the water. Watch for ten minutes and take it out before the water reaches the top. Compare 3 or 4 colours. Which pens are pure? Which dye travelled furthest? Does one chromatogram prove which pen drew a mystery line? What else would make you more confident? Never use alcohol or nail polish remover; never use marker ink.

Practice
1
A black felt-tip pen gives a chromatogram with three coloured spots. Is the black ink a pure substance? Explain.
2
Look at the chromatogram. Which pen contains only one dye? Which two pens share a blue dye? How can you tell?
pen Dpen Epen Fstart linesolvent front
3
On a chromatogram the solvent front is 8 cm above the start line. One dye spot is 6 cm up and another is 2 cm up. What fraction of the way to the front did each travel? Which dye is more soluble?
4
Why can water be used as the solvent for the dyes in coloured sweets, but not for permanent marker ink?