Planning a solubility investigation; paper chromatography
Week 5 · Unit 2 · 2.3–2.4 · 3 lessons
2
Can we trust it?
Learner’s Book 8: Topics 2.3–2.4, pp. 47–61
GoalEvaluate results for accuracy and reliability, find anomalous results, and write a conclusion supported by the evidence.
New words
accurate · close to the true valuereliable · gives similar results when repeatedanomalous result · a result that does not fit the pattern of the othersconclusion · a statement of what the evidence shows
Explanation
After the results, a scientist asks: can I trust them? Accurate results are close to the true value, and you get them by careful measuring: reading a thermometer or a jug at eye level, measuring to the nearest unit, and using the best apparatus. Reliable results are similar when the test is repeated. This is why you repeat each measurement at least three times and calculate a mean. If one repeat is very different from the others, it is an anomalous result. Look for the cause, repeat the test, and leave it out of the mean (saying that you did and why). Plot the mean on a graph. A line graph shows a pattern. Draw a smooth line or a line of best fit through the points, not a join-the-dots line, and describe the trend. A conclusion must match the results, answer the question and use scientific ideas. Finally, suggest improvements, for example more temperatures, smaller intervals, a better way of timing, or more repeats.
Worked examples
Try
Mass dissolved (g)
1
36
2
35
3
52 (anomalous)
repeat
36
Tom measures how many grams of salt dissolve in 100 g of water. His three results are 36 g, 35 g and 52 g. The 52 g is anomalous because it is far from the others and does not fit. He repeats the test and gets 36 g. The mean of the good results is (36 + 35 + 36) ÷ 3, which is about 36 g.
Conclusion from the graph: as the temperature of the water goes up, the time for sugar to dissolve goes down. At 20 °C it takes about 98 s and at 60 °C about 20 s. This matches the prediction. Particles in hotter water move faster and separate the sugar sooner.
Problem
Improvement
hard to see when all sugar has dissolved
use a clear glass on a dark background and the same person judges each time
water cools while testing
measure the temperature at the start and end; use a lid or insulated cup
only 3 repeats
do 5 repeats to be more reliable
Improvements: use more temperatures, measure the temperature again at the end, use a timer that stops at the exact moment, and ask someone else to check when the sugar has gone.
Class activity
Look at a set of results. Copy and complete the table: Temperature 20 °C: 98, 94, 102 s; 30 °C: 64, 60, 62 s; 40 °C: 40, 42, 41 s; 50 °C: 31, 29, 58 s (a repeat of the 58 s test gave 30 s); 60 °C: 21, 19, 20 s. Which result is anomalous? Calculate the mean at each temperature, using the repeat result of 30 s instead of the anomalous one. Draw a graph on squared paper with the temperature along the bottom. Draw a smooth line. Write a conclusion and one improvement. Then do your own test if you have done the practical in Lesson 1, and compare.
Practice
1
What is the difference between accurate and reliable results?
Accurate results are close to the true value. Reliable results are similar every time the experiment is repeated.
2
Ben times a tablet three times: 45 s, 51 s and 48 s. Calculate the mean time.
(45 + 51 + 48) ÷ 3 = 144 ÷ 3 = 48 s.
3
Which point on the graph is probably anomalous, and what should the scientist do?
The point at 50 °C (150 s) is far from the pattern. The scientist should check for a mistake, repeat the measurement and leave it out of the mean if it was an error.
4
Write a conclusion for the results in the lesson, then give one way to make the experiment more accurate.
As the water temperature rises, the time for the sugar to dissolve falls, because the particles move faster. More accurate: read the thermometer carefully at eye level and use a stopwatch.