Planning a solubility investigation; paper chromatography
Answers are for parents and teachers.
1
Write a plan to find out whether stirring affects how fast salt dissolves. Name the independent, dependent and control variables.
Independent: number of stirs (or stirring or not). Dependent: time to dissolve. Control: mass of salt, volume and temperature of water.
2
A student gets 12 s, 14 s, 13 s and 30 s. Which result is anomalous? Calculate the mean without it.
30 s is anomalous. Mean = (12 + 14 + 13) ÷ 3 = 13 s.
3
Do the chromatography with two different felt-tip pens at home with an adult and stick the strip in your book. What does it show?
It shows whether each colour is a pure dye or a mixture of dyes, with each dye at its own height.
4
Explain in your own words why spots rise to different heights on a chromatogram.
The solvent dissolves the dyes and carries them upwards. Dyes that are more soluble are carried further; less soluble ones stay lower.
5
Some sweets were left in a jar of syrup and coloured it. A chromatogram of the syrup shows spots at the same heights as sweets A and C. Does this prove which sweets were used? What would make you more confident?
It suggests those sweets, but similar dyes could travel the same height. Repeat the test and compare more sweets or other evidence, such as the ingredient lists.