Planning a solubility investigation; paper chromatography
Week 5 · Unit 2 · 2.3–2.4 · 3 lessons
1
Plan a fair test
Learner’s Book 8: Topics 2.3–2.4, pp. 47–61
GoalIdentify independent, dependent and control variables and write a plan for a fair test with a prediction and a results table.
New words
independent variable · the variable you change on purposedependent variable · the variable you measure to see the effectcontrol variable · a variable you keep the same to make the test fairrange and interval · the lowest and highest values you test, and the gap between them
Explanation
A good investigation starts with a question, such as: how does the temperature of water change the time it takes sugar to dissolve? The things that could change the result are called variables. The variable you change is the independent variable, here the temperature of the water. The variable you measure is the dependent variable, here the time to dissolve. All the others must stay the same, and these are the control variables: the amount of sugar, the volume of water, the type of sugar, the way you stir. If more than one thing changes, you cannot tell which caused the result. Plan the range of the independent variable, such as 20 °C to 60 °C, and the interval, such as steps of 10 °C. Make a prediction before you start, using science to give a reason. Prepare a results table with units in the headings, and repeat each test to check reliability. On a graph, the independent variable goes along the horizontal axis and the dependent variable up the vertical axis.
Kind of variable
In this plan
independent (change)
water temperature, 20–60 °C
dependent (measure)
time to dissolve, in seconds
control (keep the same)
sugar, volume of water, stirring
Worked examples
question→prediction with a reason→plan: variables, method, safety→results table→graph and conclusion
Kenji’s plan: Question: does hotter water dissolve sugar faster? Prediction: the hotter the water, the less time, because the water particles move faster and mix with the sugar particles more quickly.
Temperature (°C)
Try 1 (s)
Try 2 (s)
Try 3 (s)
Mean (s)
20
30
40
50
60
A results table has a column for the independent variable and columns for the repeats, with units in the headings.
Control variable
How I keep it the same
volume of water
100 ml in a measuring jug each time
mass of sugar
one level teaspoon every time
stirring
10 gentle stirs each time
sugar type
same packet of granulated sugar
Nodira wants to keep the test fair. She writes the control variables and how she will control each.
Class activity
Plan the investigation on paper first, then do it with an adult. The adult prepares five glasses of 100 ml of water at about 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40 °C (mixing cold and warm tap water, nothing hotter than a warm bath, and checking each with the thermometer); you only read the thermometer, add the sugar and stir. Add one level teaspoon of sugar and start a stopwatch. Stir gently in the same way until you cannot see any sugar and stop the clock. Record each time in your table; repeat each temperature three times. Identify the independent, dependent and control variables. Write a prediction before you start. Safety: no hot water at all; the adult fills and carries the glasses. (The results in the next lesson come from a school laboratory with hotter water.)
Practice
1
In the plan above, which is the independent variable, the dependent variable and one control variable?
Independent: temperature of the water. Dependent: time for the sugar to dissolve. Control: for example, volume of water or mass of sugar.
2
Ana tests how the volume of water affects how much salt dissolves. Name the variable she changes and the one she measures. Give two she keeps the same.
She changes the volume of water and measures the mass of salt that dissolves. She keeps the temperature and the type of salt (and the stirring) the same.
3
Omar uses 50 ml of water at 20 °C and 100 ml of water at 40 °C. Explain why the test is not fair.
Two variables changed: the volume of water and the temperature. He cannot tell which caused the difference. Only the temperature should change.
4
Mia times how long an effervescent tablet takes to dissolve in water at different temperatures. Which axis does the temperature go on? Write a good label for each axis.
Temperature of water (°C)
Time to dissolve (s)
20
80
30
55
40
35
The temperature is the independent variable, so it goes on the horizontal (x) axis: ‘temperature of water (°C)’. The time is the dependent variable, so it goes up the vertical (y) axis: ‘time to dissolve (s)’.