GoalDescribe how a persistent insecticide spreads and why it can harm animals that nobody meant to kill.
New words
insecticide · a chemical that kills insectspersistent · does not break down, so it stays in the environment for a very long timetoxic · poisonous to living thingsbiodegradable · can be broken down by decomposers and other microorganisms
Explanation
Imagine an insecticide called pesticide X, sprayed on potato fields to kill the beetles that eat the plants. Pesticide X is very good at killing insects, so at first it looks like a perfect answer. But it is persistent: decomposers cannot break it down, so it stays in soil and water for many years. Wind and rain also carry it far from the place where it was sprayed. It is toxic to many animals besides insects, and chemicals like it can stop some birds from breeding, for example by weakening their eggshells. Decomposers can break down material that was once alive, such as leaves and dead animals, but not every chemical made by people. A biodegradable insecticide is different, because microorganisms in the soil, in water or inside animals break it down, so it does not last. This is the central question for a scientist: how long does the chemical stay, and where does it go?
pesticide X is sprayed→wind and rain carry it far away→decomposers cannot break it down→it stays for years in soil and water→living things take it in
Worked examples
Persistent insecticide
Biodegradable insecticide
time in the environment
many years
days or weeks
broken down by microorganisms?
no
yes
builds up in animals?
yes
hardly at all
harm to other species
long-lasting
short-lived
how often it must be sprayed
rarely
more often
A persistent insecticide compared with a biodegradable one.
Time
What people noticed
year 1
fewer beetles and bigger potato harvests
year 6
fewer chicks hatch in nests by the lake; shells are thin
year 9
tests find pesticide X in fish far from the lake
Why the harm was not seen at first. The insects were killed quickly, which looked like a success, while the damage to other animals appeared slowly and far away.
Decomposers break down material that was once alive. Many materials made by people are not broken down in this way.
Class activity
Rotting test, with an adult. Plan a fair test of which materials decay in garden soil. An adult digs four holes of the same depth in damp soil, and you put a small piece of apple peel in one, paper in another, a piece of cotton cloth in the third and a piece of a plastic bag in the fourth. Mark each place with a stick. Predict which will rot. After two weeks the adult and you dig them up carefully, wearing gloves, and compare them. Wash your hands. What did you keep the same? Which material would be like a persistent chemical? Remember that a plastic bag is not an insecticide but it shows what ‘not broken down’ looks like.
Practice
1
Explain what ‘persistent’ and ‘toxic’ mean when scientists describe pesticide X.
Persistent means that it does not break down, so it lasts for years in nature. Toxic means that it is poisonous to living things, including animals that were not meant to be killed.
2
Give one reason why people thought pesticide X was a good idea and one reason why it later became a problem.
It killed crop pests very well, so less of the harvest was lost. Later it was found to stay in the environment, spread far and harm other animals such as fish-eating birds.
3
The graph shows how much of two insecticides is left in soil. Which one is persistent? Give evidence from the graph.
Insecticide X is persistent: 80% is still in the soil after five years. Insecticide Y is biodegradable: it falls to 0% after five years and to 10% after only two years.
4
Insecticide Y breaks down much faster than insecticide X (see the graph above). Give one advantage and one disadvantage compared with insecticide X.
Insecticide X
Insecticide Y
time for half to break down
more than 10 years
less than 1 year
number of sprays needed in a year
1
6
Advantage: it does not stay in the environment or build up in animals. Disadvantage: it must be sprayed more often, which may cost more.