Evidence for evolution from comparative anatomy and palaeontology
Comparative anatomy compares the structure of organs. Homologous organs have the same origin and structure but may have different functions: the human arm, whale flipper, bat and bird wings – all have humerus, radius, ulna, wrist bones and finger bones; in plants a pea tendril and a barberry spine are modified leaves. Homology shows a common ancestor (divergent evolution). Analogous organs have similar functions but different origins: the wings of a butterfly and a bird, a cactus spine (leaf) and a hawthorn spine (shoot); they result from adaptation to a similar environment (convergence). Vestigial organs were fully developed in ancestors and are now reduced: the side toes of a horse, the pelvic bones of a whale; in humans the coccyx (tailbone), wisdom teeth and ear muscles (the appendix has also shrunk and has other functions). Atavism is the return of an ancestral trait in some individuals: a tail-like outgrowth or thick hair cover present from birth in humans (very rare), side toes in horses. Palaeontology: fossils show the history of life; transitional forms link groups: Archaeopteryx (about 150 million years ago) – toothed, long-tailed, with feathers – has reptile and bird features; Tiktaalik (about 375 million years ago) lies between fish and the first land vertebrates; the horse phylogenetic series runs from small many-toed ancestors through three-toed forms (for example Hipparion) to the present one-toed horse; whale ancestors show the move from land hoofed animals to water. Fossils lie in order in strata: simple and ancient in deep layers, more complex and closer to modern forms above.
| Organs | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Homologous | same origin, different function | human arm, whale flipper, bat wing |
| Analogous | similar function, different origin | butterfly and bird wings |
| Vestigial | reduced | horse side toes, human coccyx |
| Atavism | ancestral trait returns | side toes in a horse |
In a natural history museum, a fossil tooth or bone fragment is identified by comparing it with those of familiar animals. Homologous structures help: bones with the same plan look different in different animals.
A palaeontologist identifies fossils, a museum preparator prepares bones, and an archaeologist studies bones found at a site.
Feel the joints of your own index finger and count its bones (three), then picture a bat’s wing and think where the same bones would be.
| Archaeopteryx | Features |
|---|---|
| Bird | feathers, wings, fused collarbone |
| Reptile | toothed jaws, long bony tail, claws on digits |
“Homology or analogy?”: pairs of pictures (human arm, whale flipper, bird and butterfly wings, cactus and hawthorn spines) are shown and students answer with cards.