AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Contents · Biology

Evidence for evolution

Lessons 50–51 · 2 lessons · A. G‘afurov, A. Abdukarimov, J. Tolipova, O. Ishankulov, M. Umaraliyeva, I. Abdurahmonova. Biology, Grade 10, 1st edition. “Sharq” publishing and printing joint-stock company, Tashkent, 2017
51

Evidence for evolution from comparative anatomy and palaeontology

Textbook: pp. 204–206
GoalExplain the evidence of comparative anatomy (homologous, analogous, vestigial organs, atavism) and palaeontology (transitional forms, phylogenetic series).
New words
homologous organs · gomologik organlaranalogous organs · analogik organlarvestigial organ · rudimentatavism · atavizm
Explanation

Comparative anatomy compares the structure of organs. Homologous organs have the same origin and structure but may have different functions: the human arm, whale flipper, bat and bird wings – all have humerus, radius, ulna, wrist bones and finger bones; in plants a pea tendril and a barberry spine are modified leaves. Homology shows a common ancestor (divergent evolution). Analogous organs have similar functions but different origins: the wings of a butterfly and a bird, a cactus spine (leaf) and a hawthorn spine (shoot); they result from adaptation to a similar environment (convergence). Vestigial organs were fully developed in ancestors and are now reduced: the side toes of a horse, the pelvic bones of a whale; in humans the coccyx (tailbone), wisdom teeth and ear muscles (the appendix has also shrunk and has other functions). Atavism is the return of an ancestral trait in some individuals: a tail-like outgrowth or thick hair cover present from birth in humans (very rare), side toes in horses. Palaeontology: fossils show the history of life; transitional forms link groups: Archaeopteryx (about 150 million years ago) – toothed, long-tailed, with feathers – has reptile and bird features; Tiktaalik (about 375 million years ago) lies between fish and the first land vertebrates; the horse phylogenetic series runs from small many-toed ancestors through three-toed forms (for example Hipparion) to the present one-toed horse; whale ancestors show the move from land hoofed animals to water. Fossils lie in order in strata: simple and ancient in deep layers, more complex and closer to modern forms above.

OrgansMeaningExample
Homologoussame origin, different functionhuman arm, whale flipper, bat wing
Analogoussimilar function, different originbutterfly and bird wings
Vestigialreducedhorse side toes, human coccyx
Atavismancestral trait returnsside toes in a horse
💡 Where will I use this?
In real life

In a natural history museum, a fossil tooth or bone fragment is identified by comparing it with those of familiar animals. Homologous structures help: bones with the same plan look different in different animals.

Who uses it

A palaeontologist identifies fossils, a museum preparator prepares bones, and an archaeologist studies bones found at a site.

Try it today

Feel the joints of your own index finger and count its bones (three), then picture a bat’s wing and think where the same bones would be.

Worked examples
A bat wing and a butterfly wing are analogous (both fly, but one is a bony forelimb and the other a thoracic outgrowth); a bat wing and a human arm are homologous (the same bone plan).
ArchaeopteryxFeatures
Birdfeathers, wings, fused collarbone
Reptiletoothed jaws, long bony tail, claws on digits
Archaeopteryx has feathers, wings and a fused collarbone (bird features) and also toothed jaws, a long bony tail and claws on the digits (reptile features) – a transitional form between two groups.
Class activity

“Homology or analogy?”: pairs of pictures (human arm, whale flipper, bird and butterfly wings, cactus and hawthorn spines) are shown and students answer with cards.

Practice
1
Write the difference between homologous and analogous organs with examples.
2
Distinguish a vestigial organ from an atavism.
3
Archaeopteryx lived 150 million years ago and Tiktaalik 375 million years ago. What is the difference in million years? (Number only.)
4
Why are transitional forms evidence for evolution?
Story of the Week · The Khwarizmi WayA short circuit — the best way?Close the week: all of this week’s subjects in one storyRead →