☰ Contents · Biology

Evidence for evolution

Lessons 50–51 · 2 lessons · A. G‘afurov, A. Abdukarimov, J. Tolipova, O. Ishankulov, M. Umaraliyeva, I. Abdurahmonova. Biology, Grade 10, 1st edition. “Sharq” publishing and printing joint-stock company, Tashkent, 2017
50

Evidence for evolution from molecular biology, cytology and embryology

Textbook: pp. 199–203
GoalExplain how data from molecular biology, cytology and embryology prove evolution; describe embryonic similarity and the relation of phylogeny and ontogeny.
New words
phylogeny · filogenezontogenesis · ontogenezmolecular clock · molekular soatgenetic code · genetik kod
Explanation

Macroevolution, which cannot be observed directly, is studied through indirect evidence. Molecular biology: in all organisms hereditary information is in DNA (RNA in some viruses), the genetic code is almost the same (one codon – one amino acid), protein synthesis takes place on ribosomes, ATP is the universal energy carrier – this points to a common origin of life. Protein and DNA sequences are compared between species: close species differ little, distant species much. For example human and chimpanzee DNA sequences are about 98–99 % identical; cytochrome c of human and macaque differs by only 1 amino acid, of human and horse by about 12. Because differences accumulate over time, a “molecular clock” helps estimate when species diverged. The α and β chains of haemoglobin (141 and 146 amino acids) have similar sequences – they result from duplication and divergence of one ancestral gene. Cytology: all organisms are made of cells (cell theory), and cells share organelles and membranes. Embryology: vertebrate embryos are similar at early stages (gill slits, tail, notochord), and class-specific features appear later (K. von Baer’s law). E. Haeckel proposed the biogenetic law (ontogeny is a brief repetition of phylogeny); in the modern view ontogeny repeats the embryonic stages, not the adult forms, of ancestors, and some stages drop out or change (A. Severtsov’s theory of phylembryogenesis: useful mutations change embryonic stages and thereby change phylogeny).

Worked examples
In cytochrome c the human–chimpanzee difference is 0, human–macaque 1, human–horse 12 and human–yeast about 44: the larger the difference, the more ancient the common ancestor – this shows degree of relatedness.
Gill slits appear in the embryos of humans, chickens and fish. In fish they become gills; in land vertebrates they become other structures (for example parts of the ear and neck glands) – a sign of a common ancestor.
Class activity

“Molecular tree”: groups get a table of amino-acid differences between species and draw a “family tree” based on the numbers.

Practice
1
What does the uniformity of the genetic code show?
2
What can be concluded from the analysis of embryonic development?
3
Haemoglobin α chain has 141 and β chain 146 amino acids. How many amino acids in total in one molecule (2 α + 2 β)? (Number only.)
4
Why is Haeckel’s rule “ontogeny repeats phylogeny” stated more carefully now?