GoalPlan and carry out a fair test of one factor, record the results in a table, find means and choose the right graph.
New words
independent variable · the one thing you changedependent variable · the thing you measurecontrol variable · something kept the samereliable · gives similar results when repeated
Explanation
Test one factor at a time. If you test the number of turns, the number of turns is the independent variable and the number of clips held is the dependent variable. Everything else is a control variable: the same nail, cell, size of paperclip and time with the switch on. Make a prediction first and record the results in a table. Repeat the test, and a third time if two runs disagree by a lot, then find the mean. Check for anomalous results, which do not fit the pattern. When the independent variable is a number, such as the number of turns, use a line graph with it on the horizontal axis. When it is a category, such as the type of core, use a bar chart, because there is nothing between ‘wood’ and ‘iron’. In your conclusion say what the pattern is, quote values from the table, and do not claim more than the evidence shows.
Change
Measure
Keep the same
number of turns
clips held
nail, cell, clip size, time
type of core
clips held
turns, cell, clip size, time
Worked examples
Turns
Run 1
Run 2
Mean
6
1
2
1.5
12
3
3
3
18
4
5
4.5
24
6
7
6.5
30
8
8
8
The results for turns. Two runs are made and the mean is found for each number of turns, for example (1 + 2) ÷ 2 = 1.5 clips for 6 turns.
The line graph. The turns go along the bottom and the clips go up the side. The points rise steadily, so more turns means more clips. A line of best fit can be used to read values between the points.
Why a bar chart for cores. The types of core are separate categories, so the bars do not touch.
Class activity
Make your own results sheet. With an adult, test 8, 16 and 24 turns with one cell. Draw a table with columns for turns, run 1, run 2 and mean. Fill in your predictions before you start. Use the same nail, cell and clips each time. After the tests, draw a line graph on squared paper with turns along the bottom. Underline in your table any result that does not fit the pattern and repeat it. Write one sentence for your conclusion that uses numbers from your table. Switch the electromagnet on only for a few seconds each time.
Practice
1
Work out the mean for 12 turns if run 1 holds 3 clips, run 2 holds 5 clips and run 3 holds 4 clips.
Turns
Run 1
Run 2
Run 3
12
3
5
4
(3 + 5 + 4) ÷ 3 = 4 clips.
2
Use the graph to read how many clips 15 turns would hold. Is your answer a measured value or an estimate?
About 3 clips. It is an estimate, because 15 turns was not tested: it is read from the line between the points for 10 and 20 turns.
3
Which kind of graph suits each result set? (a) clips held for 5, 10, 15 and 20 turns; (b) clips held for four different rods; (c) clips held for currents from 0.2 A to 1.0 A.
(a) a line graph, (b) a bar chart, (c) a line graph. Turns and current are numbers on a scale, but the rods are separate categories.
4
The runs for 20 turns give 6, 7 and 15 clips. Which result is anomalous, and what should you do?
Turns
Run 1
Run 2
Run 3
20
6
7
15
15 is anomalous. Repeat it, and leave it out of the mean if it cannot be repeated.