GoalPlan a fair investigation into the reactivity of metals with dilute acid, record and judge the results, and explain how to work safely with chemicals.
New words
control variable · something that is kept the same so that the test is fairanomalous result · a result that does not fit the pattern of the othersrisk assessment · thinking about what could go wrong and how to stop itaccurate · close to the true value
Explanation
To compare metals you change one thing only, the type of metal. Everything else is a control variable and stays the same: the same acid, volume, strength and starting temperature, and the same mass and shape of metal, because a powder reacts faster than a lump. Measure the same thing for each metal, such as the volume of hydrogen collected in one minute. Make a prediction first, record the results in a table and repeat each test. A result that does not fit the pattern is anomalous, so repeat it and leave it out of the mean. Measuring gas in a syringe is more accurate than counting bubbles, because bubbles differ in size. Before starting, do a risk assessment: wear eye protection, tie back long hair, use small amounts, never taste anything, keep flames away from hydrogen and wash hands afterwards.
Change
Keep the same
Measure
type of metal
acid, volume, starting temperature, mass and shape of metal
hydrogen collected in 1 minute
Worked examples
Test
1
2
3
4
hydrogen (cm³)
17
18
31
19
Repeats and the mean. Zinc is tested four times. The results are 17, 18, 31 and 19 cm³. The 31 cm³ does not fit, so it is anomalous. Leaving it out, the mean is (17 + 18 + 19) ÷ 3 = 18 cm³.
Method
Good point
Weak point
count bubbles
needs no equipment
bubbles differ in size, easy to lose count
gas syringe
reads volume in cm³
needs more equipment
Why accuracy matters. Counting bubbles is quick but each bubble has a different size. A gas syringe reads the volume of hydrogen directly in cm³, so the difference between a fast metal and a slow one is clearer.
Rule
Reason
wear eye protection
splashes of acid can hurt eyes
use small amounts
less to spill, less gas made
no flames nearby
hydrogen burns easily
wash hands afterwards
acid or metal pieces may stay on skin
Safety is part of the plan. Each rule has a reason, which makes it easier to remember.
Class activity
Kitchen risk assessment, with an adult. Choose one safe job that you do with an adult, such as carrying a tray of plastic cups across a room or setting the table. Make a table with three columns: what could go wrong, who could be hurt, and what you will do to prevent it. Write at least three rows. Then do the job with the adult and add one new row for something you did not expect. This is how scientists plan chemical work. Finally design a small poster of three safety rules for a younger child, with a picture and a reason for each rule.
Practice
1
Ravi tests two metals in acid. He uses magnesium ribbon with 20 cm³ of acid, and zinc powder with 10 cm³ of acid. Give two reasons the test is not fair.
Metal
Form
Volume of acid (cm³)
magnesium
ribbon
20
zinc
powder
10
The metals are in different forms (ribbon and powder) and the volume of acid is different. Both must be the same.
2
Hydrogen collected in three repeats for iron is 4, 5 and 12 cm³. Which is anomalous, and what is the mean without it?
Repeat
1
2
3
hydrogen (cm³)
4
5
12
12 cm³ is anomalous. The mean of the other two is (4 + 5) ÷ 2 = 4.5 cm³.
3
Say what each item protects you from when working with acid.
Goggles protect the eyes from splashes. Soap and water wash off acid or metal from the hands. A running tap is for rinsing a splash from skin.
4
Write a prediction for an investigation into zinc, iron and copper in the same dilute acid, and give a reason.
Zinc will react fastest, iron more slowly and copper not at all, because the order of reactivity is zinc, iron, copper.