GoalCompare how fast different metals react with dilute acid and use the evidence to put them in order of reactivity.
New words
more reactive · reacts faster and more strongly with the same substanceorder of reactivity · a list of metals from the most reactive to the least reactiveunreactive · does not react, or reacts very slowlyevidence · observations or measurements that support an idea
Explanation
The same dilute acid can be used to compare metals. The more reactive the metal, the faster the hydrogen bubbles form, the faster the metal shrinks and the more the temperature rises. In a school test magnesium fizzes quickly, zinc more slowly, iron very slowly and copper not at all. So the order of reactivity is magnesium, zinc, iron, copper. This matches the order from the reactions with oxygen and water. Potassium, sodium and calcium react far too violently to test in school, and gold and silver do not react. We place them in the list using other evidence, such as how they react with water. The full order is potassium, sodium, calcium, magnesium, zinc, iron, copper, silver, gold.
Worked examples
Metal
Start (°C)
Highest (°C)
Rise (°C)
magnesium
20
31
11
zinc
20
24
4
iron
20
21
1
copper
20
20
0
Reading a temperature table. The same acid at 20 °C is used for each metal and the highest temperature is recorded. The bigger the rise, the more energy was given out and the more reactive the metal.
Position
Metal
Evidence
top
potassium, sodium
react violently with cold water
next
calcium
reacts steadily with cold water
middle
magnesium, zinc, iron
react with acid, fastest first
lower
copper
no reaction with acid or water
bottom
silver, gold
stay shiny, hardly react with anything
Putting every metal in a list. The metals that were tested in the laboratory give the middle of the list. The metals that were too dangerous or too costly to test are fitted in with evidence from other reactions.
A rule to remember: the order does not change with the test. Metals that are quick to react with oxygen are also quick to react with water and with acid, so one list works for all three.
Class activity
Reactivity ladder, with no chemicals. On a sheet of paper draw a ladder with nine rungs. Make nine small cards: potassium, sodium, calcium, magnesium, zinc, iron, copper, silver and gold. Make a second set of evidence cards, for example ‘kept under oil’, ‘burns with a bright white flame when heated’, ‘fizzes slowly in acid’, ‘does not react with acid’ and ‘used for jewellery’. Ask an adult to shuffle the metal cards. Put the metals on the rungs in the order you think is correct, then match each evidence card to a metal. Check your order against the lesson and say which metals were hardest to place.
Practice
1
Four metals W, X, Y and Z are added to the same dilute acid. The table shows the bubbles seen in 30 seconds. Put them in order from most reactive to least reactive.
Metal
Bubbles in 30 s (count)
W
40
X
3
Y
0
Z
12
W, Z, X, Y (most bubbles means most reactive). Metal Y made no bubbles, so it is probably unreactive.
2
Why is sodium never tested with acid in a school laboratory?
It is so reactive that the reaction would be violent and dangerous.
3
A student says that copper is unreactive because it does not fizz in dilute acid. Do you agree? Give one more piece of evidence you could use.
Yes, no fizzing is good evidence. More evidence: copper does not react with cold water, and it only reacts slowly with oxygen when it is heated.
4
Metals A, B and C make 25, 8 and 52 cm³ of hydrogen in one minute. Put them in order of reactivity.