AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Year plan · Science

Rocks in space

Week 23 · Unit 6 · 6.6 · 3 lessons
3

Refraction detectives

Learner’s Book 8: Topic 6.6, pp. 218–229
GoalPlan and interpret an investigation of how dissolved salt or sugar changes the way water bends light, and use refraction to explain what you see.
New words
concentration · how much of a substance is dissolved in a certain amount of liquidsolution · a liquid with a substance dissolved in itfair test · a test in which only the independent variable is changedresolution · the smallest difference a measuring tool can show reliably
Explanation

When you pour a clear salt or sugar solution into clear water, you see wavy lines where they meet. This is because light travels at slightly different speeds in the two liquids, so it is refracted where they mix. A solution with more dissolved salt makes light travel a little slower, so a ray entering it from air bends a little more. To test this, shine a thin beam into each liquid at the same angle of incidence, mark the beams and measure the angle of refraction. The independent variable is the concentration and the dependent variable is the angle. The container, the liquid volume, the angle of incidence and the temperature are controls. The differences are only about one degree, and a protractor can only be read to about one degree, so the class repeats the test many times and finds the mean. A large angle of incidence makes the differences easier to see. Once the liquids are mixed fully, the stripes disappear, as the light speed is the same everywhere.

irairwater
Worked examples
Salt in 100 g of water (g)Angle of refraction (°)
044.8
1144.2
2543.5
3343.1
Means of many readings from a class, for a ray entering the liquid at 70° from the normal. Plain water gives the largest angle (the smallest bending), and the strongest solution gives the smallest angle (the greatest bending). Glass bends the light even more, with an angle of about 39°.
salt in 100 g of water (g)angle of refraction (°)01020304243444546
The graph shows a steady fall in the angle as the concentration goes up, and the points lie close to a sloping straight line. The total change is only 1.7°, so many repeats are needed.
What you see when you pour. Both liquids are clear. The swirling layer between them has speeds of light that change from place to place, so rays are bent in different directions. After stirring the liquid is the same everywhere and the light goes straight through.
Class activity

See the layers. With an adult, dissolve about 3 tablespoons of salt in a cup of cold water. Tap water is enough, nothing is heated. Stand a tall clear glass of plain water in front of a card with thick black stripes. Tilt a spoon over the water and pour a little of the salty solution slowly down the back of the spoon. Look through the glass at the stripes. Draw what you see, predict what will happen after stirring, then stir with a clean spoon and look again. Wash your hands afterwards and do not drink anything.

Practice
1
In the class investigation, state the independent variable, the dependent variable and two control variables.
2
Use the graph to estimate the angle of refraction for a solution with 15 g of salt in 100 g of water.
salt in 100 g of water (g)angle of refraction (°)01020304243444546
3
At an angle of incidence of 20° the angle in plain water is 14.9° and in the strongest solution 14.4°. Why is 70° a better choice for the class investigation?
4
Put plain water, the 33 g salt solution and glass in order, from the least bending to the most bending of a ray entering at 70°.
MaterialAngle of refraction at 70° (°)
plain water44.8
33 g salt in 100 g of water43.1
glass38.8