GoalUse the words meteoroid, meteor and meteorite, explain what makes a crater and why the Moon has more craters than the Earth, and use evidence to judge an explanation.
New words
meteoroid · a small piece of rock or metal moving through spacemeteor · the streak of light seen when a meteoroid burns up in the air; a shooting starmeteorite · a piece of rock or metal from space that lands on the groundcrater · a bowl-shaped hole made when something hits a surface
Explanation
Small pieces of rock and metal, called meteoroids, move through space. Some are pieces of asteroids. The Earth’s gravity can pull them in. They hit the air at tens of kilometres per second and the friction with air makes them hot, so they glow and we see a streak of light called a meteor. Most burn up completely. A piece that survives and lands is called a meteorite. A large object can make a crater when it hits, because it moves so fast that it has a huge amount of energy. The Moon has lots of craters because it has no air to burn up the rocks and no weather to wear them away. On the Earth, wind, rain, plants and moving crust slowly wipe out craters. A large asteroid hits the Earth very rarely, on average once in many tens of thousands of years, but small ones hit more often.
meteoroid in space→meteor: streak of light→meteorite on the ground→crater, if big enough
Worked examples
Name
Where it is
What it is
meteoroid
in space
small rock or metal
meteor
in the air
glowing streak of light
meteorite
on the ground
the piece that lands
Names. The word depends on where the rock is and what it is doing.
Drop height (cm)
Mean crater width (mm)
10
24
20
28
30
31
40
33
50
35
A class dropped a marble from different heights onto flour dusted with cocoa and measured the width of each crater (mean of three drops). The higher the drop, the faster the marble hits, and the wider the crater. The rise gets smaller each time.
Idea
Fits the evidence?
asteroid impact
yes: raised rim, melted rock, iron-rich pieces
volcano
no: no volcanic rock nearby
sinkhole
no: no raised rim, no melted rock
mining pit
no: no records of mining
The mystery crater. In a desert there is a round hollow 1.2 km across with a raised rim of broken rock. No volcano is nearby, there are melted rock fragments and iron-rich pieces around it, and the rock is not limestone that dissolves. This fits an asteroid impact better than a sinkhole, which would have no raised rim and no melted rock.
Class activity
Make craters (outside or over newspaper, with an adult). Fill a baking tray with flour about 3 cm deep, level it, and dust the top lightly with cocoa powder through a tea strainer. Drop a marble or small round stone from 10 cm, 20 cm, 30 cm, 40 cm and 50 cm. Measure the width of the crater each time with a ruler. Repeat three times at each height and find the mean. Draw a graph with height on the x-axis. Stand back, do not breathe in the powder, and wash your hands afterwards. What do you keep the same?
Practice
1
Name each: (A) a small rock in space, (B) a streak of light in the sky, (C) a rock found on the ground that came from space.
A: meteoroid. B: meteor. C: meteorite.
2
Ben’s crater widths for drops from 10, 20, 30, 40 and 50 cm are 18, 22, 25, 33 and 29 mm. Which result is anomalous? What should he do? Estimate the width at 40 cm that fits the pattern.
The 33 mm for 40 cm is anomalous because it is too big for the pattern. He should repeat that drop. The width that fits is about 27 mm.
3
Explain why the Moon has many more craters than the Earth, even though it is hit by the same kinds of rocks.
The Moon has no atmosphere to burn rocks up, and no wind, water or plants to wear craters away. The Earth’s air burns up many rocks, and weather and moving crust erase old craters.
4
Why is ‘a raised rim of broken rock around the hole’ evidence for an impact rather than for a sinkhole?
An impact throws broken rock outwards and piles it round the edge. A sinkhole is a collapse into the ground, so material falls in and no raised rim is made.