GoalCompare renewable and non-renewable resources, weigh up their advantages and problems, and judge evidence about climate change.
New words
renewable resource · a resource that is replaced quickly or never runs out, such as wind or sunlightnon-renewable resource · a resource that cannot be replaced in a human lifetime, such as coal, oil and gasbiodegradable · able to be broken down by microorganismsbioplastic · a plastic made from plant material instead of oil
Explanation
Burning fossil fuels in power stations makes electricity but also releases carbon dioxide, and the fuels will run out. A renewable resource does not run out, or is replaced quickly. Wind turbines turn in moving air, tidal power uses the rise and fall of the sea, and photovoltaic cells change sunlight into electricity. None of these releases carbon dioxide while working, but each has a problem: no wind means no power, solar cells give less at night and in cloud, and a tidal barrier can change the habitats of an estuary. Building them also uses materials and energy. Bioplastics are made from plant material such as sugar, starch or vegetable oil, and many are biodegradable, but only in the right conditions. So we also need to reduce, reuse and recycle. To judge claims about climate, look at the evidence: many measurements over a long time are stronger than a single hot summer.
Source
Works when
Main problem
wind
the wind blows
no electricity on calm days
solar
the Sun shines
less at night and in cloud
tidal
the tide moves, twice a day
a barrier can harm wildlife
gas power station
any time
adds carbon dioxide; will run out
Worked examples
Lola’s town uses electricity from several sources. Renewable share = wind + solar + hydroelectric = 20 + 10 + 5 = 35%. The other 65% comes from coal and gas, which are non-renewable and release carbon dioxide.
Biodegradable or not? An apple core, a banana skin, a leaf and a paper bag are broken down by microorganisms in weeks or months. A plastic bottle, a bucket and headphones last for years, so single-use items made of them cause litter and waste.
more fuel burned→more carbon dioxide in the air→more heat kept in→warmer climate
Two scientists argue. One says carbon dioxide and temperature rose together, so humans are the cause. Another says climate has changed naturally before. A good answer uses both facts: past changes (such as ice ages) took thousands of years, while the recent rise happened in about 200 years and matches the amount of fuel burned.
Class activity
Home energy and waste check. With an adult, for two days write down every electric thing that was on in the home, how long it was on, and whether anyone was using it. In a second column write down every single-use plastic item you throw away (look at the clean recycling, do not touch dirty rubbish). Draw a bar chart of the items. Choose one change that could cut the numbers and say how you would test if it worked.
Practice
1
Sort these into renewable and non-renewable: sunlight, wind, waves, petrol. Explain how you decided.
Renewable: sunlight, wind and waves (they are not used up). Non-renewable: petrol, because it comes from oil that took millions of years to form.
2
In a village, coal makes 30% of the electricity, gas 20%, wind 35% and solar 15%. What percentage is renewable? Which is the biggest single source?
Renewable: 35 + 15 = 50%. The biggest single source is wind (35%).
3
Give one reason why a bioplastic bag is not a complete answer to plastic waste.
Many bioplastics only break down in the right conditions (warmth, microorganisms), growing the plants uses land, and a bag thrown away as litter is still waste. Reducing and reusing is better.
4
Which is stronger evidence for a warming climate: (a) one very hot week in your town, or (b) temperature records from many places over 100 years? Explain.
(b). A single week is weather and could be chance. Many measurements from many places over a long time show a trend.