GoalExplain the greenhouse effect, how human activity has added extra greenhouse gases, and why this leads to global warming.
New words
greenhouse gas · a gas, such as carbon dioxide, methane or water vapour, that traps some of the heat leaving the Earthgreenhouse effect · the natural warming of the Earth because greenhouse gases keep some heat inglobal warming · the rise in the Earth’s average temperature caused by extra greenhouse gasesemissions · gases released into the air by human activities
Explanation
Sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the ground and the sea. The warm surface gives out heat, and some of it travels up towards space. Greenhouse gases absorb part of this heat and send some of it back down, so less escapes. This natural greenhouse effect is useful: without it the average temperature would be about −18 °C instead of about 15 °C. For about 200 years people have added more carbon dioxide by burning coal, oil and gas (carbon + oxygen → carbon dioxide), by cutting down forests so fewer trees take in carbon dioxide, and by heating limestone to make cement (calcium carbonate → calcium oxide + carbon dioxide). Cattle and other farming add methane. More greenhouse gas makes the ‘blanket’ thicker, so less heat escapes and the climate becomes warmer. A blanket is an analogy, which means a comparison that helps us picture an idea; like every analogy, it also has limits.
Worked examples
With more greenhouse gases the layer is thicker. Compare it with the picture above: fewer red arrows reach space and more heat is sent back to the ground. The surface gets warmer until a new balance is reached.
Measurements of carbon dioxide in the air (in parts per million, ppm) show a steady rise. From 1950 to 2020 the rise was 413 − 311 = 102 ppm. From 1800 to 2020 it was 413 − 283 = 130 ppm, which is 130 ÷ 283 ≈ 46% more than in 1800. The values are rounded.
Analogy
What it shows well
Its limit
blanket
heat is kept in
a blanket is solid; the air is a mixture of gases
greenhouse
heat gets in but cannot easily get out
a greenhouse warms mostly because the warm air is trapped
Every analogy has a strength and a limit. The strength of the blanket analogy is that it shows ‘keeping heat in’. The limit is that a blanket is solid and a person makes their own heat, while greenhouse gases are a gas and the Earth gets its heat from the Sun.
Class activity
Model it with two jars. With an adult, use two identical clear glass jars (or clear plastic bottles) and two thermometers. Put one thermometer in each jar so the bulb does not touch the glass. Put a lid on jar A. Leave jar B open. Stand them side by side on a sunny windowsill, never looking at the Sun, and read the temperatures every 10 minutes for 40 minutes. Predict first. Record your readings in a table. What was the same for both jars (fair test)? Which warmed more? The lid mainly stops warm air from rising away, which is different from how greenhouse gases work, so write one limit of this model.
Practice
1
Compare the two greenhouse pictures in this lesson. Explain why the thicker layer of gases makes the surface warmer.
The thicker layer absorbs more of the heat from the surface and sends more of it back down, so less heat escapes to space and the surface warms.
2
In 1900 the carbon dioxide level was 296 ppm and in 2000 it was 369 ppm. Work out the rise and the percentage rise from 1900 to 2000 (to the nearest whole number).
369 − 296 = 73 ppm. 73 ÷ 296 × 100 = 24.7%, so about 25%.
3
For each activity, name the gas it adds to the air or the change it causes.
Activity
Gas or change
burning petrol in a car
?
cattle digesting grass
?
heating limestone for cement
?
cutting down a forest
?
Burning petrol: carbon dioxide. Cattle: methane. Making cement from limestone: carbon dioxide. Cutting down forests: fewer trees take in carbon dioxide, so more stays in the air.
4
Ravi says: ‘The greenhouse effect is the problem, so we should get rid of all greenhouse gases.’ Explain what is wrong with this.
The natural greenhouse effect keeps the Earth warm enough for life; without it the Earth would be about −18 °C on average. The problem is the extra greenhouse gases added by people, which increase the effect.