GoalJudge whether metadata is useful, harmless or risky and explain how small facts can add up to identify a person.
New words
identify · to work out who a person iscombine · to put togetherroutine · things that someone does regularly at the same timesrisk · the chance that something bad will happen
Explanation
One scrap of metadata may seem harmless. A date alone says little. A place alone says little. But put several scraps together and a clearer picture appears. A post that shows a photo, a time and a place every Tuesday at the same park gives away a routine. Add a school bag or a team shirt and a stranger may guess where the person goes to school. So we weigh each detail. Is it useful to me, harmless or risky? Then we ask what happens if it is combined with other facts. Good habits help. Ask an adult to switch off location tags. Before sharing, look at the photo and the words for clues. Share less if you are unsure. Metadata is not bad. It helps us to sort and find things. We just need to understand it and use it wisely.
Worked examples
Three Tuesdays in a row
Post
Time
Place
Post 1
Tue 4:05 pm
Greenfield Park
Post 2
Tue 4:10 pm
Greenfield Park
Post 3
Tue 4:02 pm
Greenfield Park
Three posts from an invented profile, Kenji_T. Each one shares a little. Together they show a routine.
Small clues in a profile can combine with metadata. Here the bio and photos show that Kenji likes football and cats. Add a place and a time from his posts, and a stranger may guess where he plays.
Check
Done?
Location tag off
yes
No school name or uniform visible
yes
Everyone in the photo agrees
yes
A safe choice. Before posting, a family checks three things: location tag off, no school name or uniform in the picture, and everyone in the photo has agreed.
Class activity
Join the scraps (on paper). Invent a person with a simple profile: first name only, one hobby, a favourite park. Write four invented posts, each with a time and a place, and add one small clue (a shirt, a bag, a name tag). Swap with a partner, who lists what a stranger could work out. Then rewrite each post so that it shares less: no regular times, no places, no clues. Finally write three rules your class could follow before sharing a photo. Do not use real names, schools or places. If you have a computer or tablet, type your three rules.
Practice
1
Sort each detail from a photo as useful, harmless or risky: (a) the date it was taken, (b) the type of phone, (c) the location tag at a child’s home.
Detail
Useful, harmless or risky?
(a) Date taken
?
(b) Type of phone
?
(c) Location tag at home
?
(a) Useful for sorting photos. (b) Harmless on its own. (c) Risky, because it shows where a child lives. Combined details can matter more than one alone.
2
Read the three posts. What routine do they give away, and why is it a problem?
Post
Time
Place
1
Tue 4:00 pm
Maple Court Pool
2
Tue 4:03 pm
Maple Court Pool
3
Tue 4:01 pm
Maple Court Pool
They show that the person is at the same pool every Tuesday around 4 pm. A stranger could use this to find them, so it is risky to share regular times and places.
3
Write two changes that make this post safer: ‘Practice at Maple Court Pool every Tuesday at 4! Look at my new team shirt!’
Take out the place and the regular time, and leave out the shirt that shows the team. For example: ‘Had a great practice!’ with no tag. Ask an adult to help check the photo.
4
A pupil says: ‘Metadata is always bad.’ Give a reason to disagree.
Metadata is useful: it helps us sort files by date, find a photo, or search for a document. It becomes risky only when a detail such as a location is shared in a way that could harm someone.