AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
☰ Year plan · Digital Literacy

Finding good evidence

Week 27 · Unit 8.4: Protecting online activity · 3 lessons
1

Refining for reliable pages

Digital Literacy 8: Unit 8.4, objectives 8TC.05, 8DW.01
GoalChange a search step by step so that the results become more useful and more trustworthy.
New words
refine · to change a search to get better resultsreliable · able to be trusted because it is accurate and well sourcedscan · to read quickly to see if something is usefulsnippet · the short text shown under a search result
Explanation

A first search is rarely the best one. Look at the results, decide what is wrong, and change the search. Too many unrelated pages? Add a keyword or put a phrase in quotation marks. Too many shopping pages? Leave out a word with a minus sign. Pages that are too old? Use the date filter. Need pictures or news? Choose that tab. To find reliable information, add words that point to evidence, such as ‘study’, ‘report’ or ‘museum’. Scan the title, address and snippet before you open a page, and remember that the first results may be adverts. Each change should have a reason. If you change many things at once you will not know what helped.

Problem with resultsChange to try
too wideadd a keyword
wrong meaningadd or leave out a word
old pagesdate filter
adverts and shopsminus sign, add ‘report’ or ‘study’
Worked examples
beesAllImagesNewsAbout 18 000 000 resultsABuy a bee costumeAdwww.example.com/shopFancy dress for all ages.BBee cartoons for kidswww.example.net/fun2 Mar 2021Colouring and games.CHow bees pollinate cropswww.example.org/farm5 May 2024A report on pollination.
Round one: a pupil researching how bees help crops gets many shops and cartoons.
bees pollination crops reportAllImagesNewsAbout 24 000 resultsAHow bees pollinate cropswww.example.org/farm5 May 2024A report on pollination.BFarm study: bees and appleswww.example.net/study12 Aug 2023Measured yields with and without bees.
Round two: the pupil adds keywords and a date filter.
SearchProblemChange
beestoo wideadd crops
bees cropscartoonsadd report
A refinement log records the reason for each change.
Class activity

Refinement ladder (on paper). Make a ladder of five rungs for an invented question: ‘Why do cities build green roofs?’. On each rung write a search, what is wrong with its imagined results and the change you will make. Include at least one quotation mark phrase, one minus sign and one filter. Then write a final search and three reasons why its results should be trustworthy. A partner reads the ladder and suggests one change. If you have a computer or tablet, with a trusted adult you may try one ladder rung and compare the lists.

Practice
1
A search for ‘mouse’ shows pages about computer equipment and about animals. A pupil wants the animal. Give two ways to refine it.
mouseAllImagesNewsAbout 90 000 000 resultsAWireless computer mouse on salewww.example.com/techQuiet clicks and a long battery life.BThe house mouse: a small rodentwww.example.org/animalsWhere mice live and what they eat.
2
Why add a word such as ‘report’ or ‘study’ when you need reliable facts?
3
The date filter shows pages from the last year. When is this useful, and when might it hide good pages?
4
Write one improved search for: ‘How do tides work?’ with a reason.
SearchProblem
tidestoo wide