GoalJudge a source by its author, purpose, date and evidence.
New words
source · the person, book or site that information comes fromauthor · the person or group who made the contentpurpose · the reason something was made: to inform, sell, persuade or amuseevidence · facts, data or named sources that support a claim
Explanation
Anyone can put anything online, so you must judge what you read. Ask four questions about a page. Who made it, and why would they know about this topic? What is the purpose: to inform, to sell, to persuade or to amuse? When was it written, and could the facts have changed? What evidence is given, such as named sources, numbers or an expert? A page by a museum about its own collection is a good source for that collection. An advert about the best bicycle tyre wants you to buy. An opinion is what someone thinks; a fact can be checked. Good judges also look for a second and third source that agree, because one source can be wrong.
Question
What to look for
Who?
a named author or organisation that knows the topic
Why?
inform, sell, persuade or amuse
When?
a date that fits the topic
Evidence?
named sources, data, experts
Worked examples
Page A
Page B
Author
Harbour Museum, named curator
no name
Purpose
inform
sell
Date
2024
not shown
Evidence
lists its sources
‘everyone says’
Two invented pages about the same topic. Page A is written by a museum, Page B by a seller.
Sentence
Kind
The river is 12 km long.
fact
The river is the prettiest in the world.
opinion
Fact or opinion? A fact can be checked. An opinion is a view.
Dates matter. Old facts can be out of date, like a bus timetable from several years ago.
Class activity
Source detective (on paper). Prepare three invented page descriptions about ‘how much sleep 12-year-olds need’: a health clinic leaflet with a named doctor and a date, a mattress advert, and an unsigned post with no date. For each, fill in a four-row table: author, purpose, date, evidence. Rank them from most to least reliable and explain the order with ‘because’. Then write a fact and an opinion about sleep, and a partner marks which is which.
Practice
1
Name the purpose of each: a bus company timetable, a toy advert, a comedy sketch, a campaign page asking you to vote for a school rule.