GoalCompare ways of communicating by ease of use, cost, reliability and the alternative of meeting face to face.
New words
benefit · a good result or advantagelimitation · something that stops a method working wellreliable · working well every time you need itbandwidth · how much data a connection can carry each second
Explanation
To judge a way of communicating, ask four questions. Is it easy to use? A voice message is easier than a long email, but not everyone can use a new tool quickly. What does it cost? The cost is not only money. It includes time and travel, and also the effect on the environment, because a video call saves a car journey. Is it reliable? A video call needs good bandwidth and power, and may fail during bad weather or a service problem. What is the alternative? Meeting face to face lets people shake hands and read body language, but takes time and travel. There is no single right answer. The best choice depends on the purpose, the people and what is available to them.
Question
What to think about
Ease of use
Do all people know how to use it?
Cost
Money, time, travel and the environment
Reliability
Connection, power, service
The alternative
What would meeting face to face give?
Worked examples
Members
Minutes each way
Round trip
Time saved by the call
6
25
50
300 minutes (5 hours)
The invented Riverbank Library committee has 6 members. Each would travel 25 minutes each way to meet in person. A video call saves that travel time. Total time saved: 6 × 2 × 25 = 300 minutes.
Chair
Can you hear us?
Member
You are freezing! I will type my answer.
A video call has limits. One member has a weak connection and the picture keeps freezing. A text chat would be more reliable for her.
Purpose
Better method
Reason
Check a violin hold
face to face
teacher can see and gently correct
Change of lesson time
text message
quick and clear
Face to face can be better. A school music teacher judges a child’s hand position best in the room. For a quick timetable change, text is enough. The best method depends on the purpose.
Class activity
Comparison chart (on paper). Choose two ways of communicating, such as a video call and a text chat. Draw a table with four rows (ease of use, cost, reliability, the alternative) and two columns. Fill in one benefit and one limit for each box. Then pick a situation, such as a family meeting with a relative abroad, and say which method you would choose and why. Compare with a partner. If you have a computer or tablet, type your table.
Practice
1
Four friends live 15 minutes from the park. They could meet in person or have a video call. Compare the two on cost and on the alternative of meeting face to face.
Way
Cost
What you get
Meet in person
?
?
Video call
?
?
Cost: meeting costs travel time and maybe money (15 minutes each way for each friend), while a call costs no travel but uses data and power. Face to face gives hugs, shared games and easier talk, which a call cannot give. Answers will vary but must mention cost and a real difference.
2
A team of 4 would each travel 45 minutes each way to a meeting. How many minutes of travel does a video call save in total?
Each person saves 45 × 2 = 90 minutes. For 4 people: 90 × 4 = 360 minutes, which is 6 hours.
3
Give two limits of a video call.
It needs a good connection and power. It can be tiring, and it uses data. Some people find it hard to talk in turn. Any two sensible limits are correct.
4
A grandmother has no computer. Which of the six ways from the last lesson might still work for her, and why?
Grandmother has
Grandmother does not have
a simple phone
a computer
A voice message may work if her phone can play recordings, because it needs no typing and no screen skills. If her phone cannot, a plain phone call or a printed letter is the better choice. Ease of use and reliability depend on what she owns and knows.