Digital Literacy 8: Unit 8.4, objectives 8TC.05, 8DW.01
GoalCompare several search results for authority, evidence and date, and choose the most reliable one.
New words
authority · knowing the subject well enough to be believedcompare · to look at things side by side to see how they are alike or differentcorroborate · to support with another sourceadvert · a paid message that tries to sell something
Explanation
Comparing results helps you choose well. Put two or three results side by side. Check who runs each site by reading the domain name from the right. A museum, a university or a public service has authority on its topic; a shop has a reason to sell. Check the date. Read the snippet for evidence. See if another source corroborates a surprising fact. An advert is marked ‘Ad’, and a paid place is not a sign of quality. The page at the top is not always best. After comparing, choose the page that gives the best evidence, and say why. If two good pages disagree, say so and find a third.
Result
Owner
Date
Evidence
Choice
A
shop
2024
none
no
B
science museum
2024
named study
yes
C
unknown
2012
none
no
Worked examples
Three invented results for ‘why do leaves change colour’.
Question
B
C
Who runs it?
a botanical garden
unknown
Evidence?
pigments explained
none
Date fits?
yes
old
Comparing in a table makes the choice visible.
When two good sources disagree, a third helps.
Class activity
Result judges (on paper). Prepare five result cards for an invented question, ‘How tall is the tallest tree?’: an advert for garden saws, a forest museum page with a date, a blog without a name, a school quiz page and an old encyclopedia entry. Label them A–E with a made-up owner and date. In pairs, rank the cards from best to worst and fill in a table: owner, date, evidence, decision. Explain your top choice in two sentences using ‘because’. Check whether another card corroborates the fact.
Practice
1
Why might the top result not be the best?
It may be an advert, or it may be popular without being accurate. Judge by owner, evidence and date.
2
Two results disagree: one says a tower is 120 m, the other 125 m. What do you do?
Source
Height
Page X
120 m
Page Y
125 m
Look for a third source, ideally from the tower’s owner or an official record, and note the difference if it remains.
3
A page is marked ‘Ad’ and says it has the best price. Is it reliable on the question ‘which is the cheapest?’ Explain.
Not on its own. An advert is paid to make its seller look good. Compare with other prices.
4
Choose the best source for ‘how does a vaccine work’ from: a pharmacy advert, a hospital’s information page with a date, an unsigned post.
The hospital’s information page: it has authority, a date and, we hope, evidence. The others sell or give no author.