Bias and leading questions
Bias is a lean to one side. A page can be biased because its maker sells something, loves a team or wants you to join a cause. Bias is not always dishonest, but it means you should look for other views. Watch for strong words such as ‘everyone knows’ and ‘the worst ever’. Look for what is left out. Questions can be biased too. A leading question pushes you to answer in a certain way: ‘Don’t you agree that the new rule is silly?’ A fair question is neutral: ‘What do you think of the new rule?’ A survey with leading questions gives results that cannot be trusted. A balanced source gives more than one side and says where its facts come from.
| Leading question | Fairer question |
|---|---|
| Don’t you agree that homework is pointless? | How useful do you find homework? |
| Wouldn’t it be better to cut break time? | What length of break time do you prefer? |
Everyone knows Brightside Cycles make the only good bikes. The rest are junk!
| Question asked | Said yes |
|---|---|
| Do you like the school garden? | 28 of 40 |
| Don’t you agree the muddy garden is a waste? | 11 of 40 |
| Source | Balanced? |
|---|---|
| Leaflet that lists good and bad points | yes |
| Advert that lists only good points | no |
Question makeover (on paper). Write eight survey questions for an invented topic, such as the length of lunch break, half of them leading and half neutral. Swap with a partner, who underlines the leading words and rewrites each leading question fairly. Then ask five classmates, for fun, one leading and one neutral version of the same question about a favourite colour or snack and compare the answers in a tally chart. Write two sentences on what you noticed.
Our juice is the best in the world!
| Question | Yes |
|---|---|
| Do you like the new library hours? | 33 of 50 |
| Don’t you agree the new library hours are too short? | 18 of 50 |