GoalWeigh the benefits and the risks of IoT devices using a worksheet-style table.
New words
benefit · a good resultrisk · a chance of harmdefault password · the first password set by the maker, which many people never changeupdate · new software that fixes faults and weak points
Explanation
Every connected object has two faces. The benefits can be convenience, saving energy and money, safety alerts, health monitoring and remote control. The risks include private data, such as a camera or a microphone that records a home. There may also be weak or unchanged default passwords, so a stranger could take control. Missing updates leave faults unfixed. If one device is taken over, it may be used to reach others on the same network. Finally, everything may stop if the connection or the company’s service ends. To weigh a device, write each benefit and each risk, and ask how likely and how serious it is. A fair answer shows both sides before making a choice.
Device (invented)
Benefit
Risk
smart heating
saves energy
needs updates
doorbell camera
shows who is at the door
records people near the home
smart speaker
hands-free help
microphone may record sound
Worked examples
Smart door lock
Benefit
Risk
Let a family member in from far away
useful if keys are lost
weak password could let a stranger in
Records who entered
helps to check
stores private routines
A worksheet-style table helps to compare. The invented smart lock has its two sides listed.
Risk
Likely?
Serious?
service stops
medium
low
default password not changed
high
high
update missed
medium
medium
Not all risks are equal. The invented table rates how likely and how serious each risk is.
Convenience can hide costs. An invented fridge that orders milk by itself saves a trip, but it sends data about food habits.
Class activity
Benefit and risk worksheet (on paper). Choose three invented devices from the home: a doorbell camera, a smart speaker and a smart light. For each, rule a table with columns ‘benefit’, ‘risk’, ‘how likely’ and ‘how serious’. Fill in at least two benefits and two risks for each. Then rank the three risks you think are most serious and give a reason. Swap with a partner, compare, and see where you disagree. If you have a computer or tablet, type your worksheet.
Practice
1
Give two benefits and two risks of a smart doorbell with a camera.
Smart doorbell
Benefit
Risk
1
?
?
2
?
?
Benefits: you can see who is there even when away, and it can help to feel safe. Risks: it records people near the door, and a weak password could let a stranger watch.
2
Why is a default password a risk?
Many people never change it, and strangers may know the maker’s common passwords, so they could take control.
3
A smart light stops working because the company ends its service. Which risk is this, and how could a family prepare?
Company ends the service→?→Lights stop responding to the app
The risk that everything stops when the service ends. The family could keep the ordinary switch working and not depend on one service for important things.
4
Which is more serious: a smart speaker that is a little slow, or a smart camera that anyone can watch? Say why.
The camera that anyone can watch, because it breaks privacy and safety. The slow speaker is only an annoyance.