GoalWeigh the benefits and risks of workplace changes from the point of view of employers and workers.
New words
employer · a person or company that gives people jobsemployee · a person who works for an employerbenefit · a good resultautomate · to make a machine do a task
Explanation
Every change brings gains and losses, and they are not the same for everyone. Email lets employers and workers reach each other quickly, but workers may feel they must answer all day. Computers did boring copying and sums, which saved time. Some old tasks, such as typing from a pile of handwritten pages, grew less common, while new jobs appeared, such as looking after computer networks. When a machine does a task, we say the task is automated. Employers often gain speed and lower costs; workers may gain easier work but may also need to learn new skills. A fair view looks at both sides and asks: Who gains? Who must adapt? What could be done to help?
Change
Benefit
Risk
Email
fast, keeps a record
messages never stop
Computers
fewer repeated tasks
some tasks disappear
Online files
reachable anywhere
need protecting
Worked examples
Employer
Worker
Benefit
orders arrive at once
can answer from anywhere
Risk
staff may be distracted
feels always on call
The employer’s view and the worker’s view of the same change can differ. The invented table compares email at a toy factory.
Copy letters by hand→A machine copies them→Worker checks the copies→Learns a new skill
A task that is automated frees time but needs new skills. The picture follows an invented worker.
Manager
We will not expect replies after 6 pm.
Worker
That helps me rest.
Both sides can help. An invented company agrees on rules so that email helps and does not harm.
Class activity
Two hats debate (on paper). Choose one change: photocopier, email or computer. On one side of a page write what the employer gains and risks; on the other write what the worker gains and risks. Use at least two points each. Swap with a partner, who adds one point to each side. Then both of you write one rule that would be fair to both sides. If you have a computer or tablet, type your two columns.
Practice
1
Give one benefit and one risk of email at work from the worker’s point of view.
Email at work
Worker
Benefit
?
Risk
?
Benefit: messages arrive at once and can be answered from anywhere. Risk: the worker may feel they must reply all day, even in the evening.
2
A factory buys a machine that does a task that ten people did. Describe one effect on the employer and one on workers.
Employer: faster work and maybe lower costs. Workers: some jobs may change or go, so training for new tasks is needed. A fair answer shows both sides.
3
What is meant by automation?
Making a machine or program do a task that people did before.
4
Suggest one fair rule that helps both employer and workers when messages can be sent at any hour.
For example: no replies are expected outside working hours except for emergencies. This protects rest for workers and clear working time for employers.