GoalExplain how scraps of information can be combined to identify an invented person and what people can do about it.
New words
combine · to put togetheridentify · to work out exactly who someone isclue · a small piece of evidencepersonal information · facts that show who a person is or where to find them
Explanation
One clue is rarely enough to name someone. A pupil who likes kites may be one of thousands. Add a town and the group is smaller. Add a school colour and it is smaller still. Add a training day and a photo with a landmark, and only a few people are left. This is how scraps can be combined to identify a person, even when none of them is a name. People who collect data often do exactly this. Adults can protect children by switching off location tags, by choosing who can see a profile and by keeping personal information off public pages. It is never kind or safe to try to find out who a real person is; this lesson uses an invented person only.
Likes kites+→Lives in a small town+→Wears a green school jumper+→Trains on Tuesdays=→Only a few people fit
Worked examples
The invented Pixel Fox club posted one photo. Each clue cuts the group of possible people. The numbers are made up.
A profile can give away more than its owner means. Here the details are invented.
A wiser version of the same card keeps the fun and removes the clues.
Class activity
Clue detective (on paper). Write six invented clue cards about a made-up child called ‘Rin’, one fact per card, for example ‘likes kites’, ‘has a brown dog’, ‘goes to a school with a green badge’, ‘plays at the park on Tuesdays’. Give the cards one at a time to a partner, who writes how many children could fit in an invented class of 200 after each clue. Afterwards, rewrite each card so that it keeps the fun but gives less away. Talk about which clues were the most powerful and why. If you have a computer or tablet, draw the bar chart in a table.
Practice
1
Which two clues about an invented child would you remove first: ‘likes kites’, ‘wears a green school jumper’, ‘trains at the old bridge every Tuesday’?
Clue
Remove?
likes kites
?
green school jumper
?
old bridge, every Tuesday
?
Remove the school jumper colour and the training place and day. Together they point to where and when the child can be found. The hobby alone is harmless.
2
Start with 500 children. A clue about the town leaves 50. A clue about the school colour leaves 10. By what number is the group divided at each step?
500 ÷ 50 = 10, so the group is divided by 10 first. 50 ÷ 10 = 5, so it is divided by 5 next. Two clues cut 500 children to 10.
3
Explain why none of the clues needs to be a name for a person to be identified.
Each clue cuts the group. When enough clues are combined, only one person may fit, so the name is not needed.
4
Name two things an adult can do to make a child’s profile safer.
Switch off location tags, choose who can see the profile, and keep school, town and routines off public pages. Any two sensible steps.