Resistance to the Red Army in the BPSR and KhPSR
After the emirâs rule was overthrown, from autumn 1920 qoârboshi groups and popular uprisings began in the western, central and eastern parts of Bukhara. The former emir Sayid Olimxon tried to gather forces in Eastern Bukhara, was defeated in March 1921 and crossed into Afghanistan; in Western Bukhara Mulla Abdulqahhor, in Eastern Bukhara Ibrohimbek and Davlatmandbek continued the struggle. In October 1921 Enver Pasha, a former Ottoman war minister, came to Bukhara by way of the Caucasus and tried to unite the commanders; he was killed in battle in August 1922 in the village of Obidara near Baljuvon. In Khorezm armed groups under Junaidxon fought the Red Army for several years (the textbook says up to 15,000 men in 1922); on 17 June 1924 he went to Herat, then returned and carried on. The textbook explains the movementâs defeat by main factors: the lack of a single centre and national programme, rivalry among leaders, the plunder by some criminal gangs, and the Red Armyâs superior weapons; concessions such as NEP also drew part of the population away from resistance. In the second period, 1925â1935, fighting continued mainly in Eastern Bukhara, Khorezm and parts of Fergana; according to the textbook, by 1935 the movement had ended and many participants emigrated.
In class there was an argument about one pupil: one person said, âalways kindâ, another said, âalways strictâ. The teacher asked both to give good and not-so-good examples. As a result the picture of the person became fuller.
Biographers and historians write about both the good and the contradictory sides of a person, museum staff write neutral label texts, and journalists use several sources in a profile.
Choose a character from a book or film you know and write two things they did well and one thing they did not do well.
âChain of causesâ: students write the causes of defeat on cards and sort them into âinternalâ and âexternalâ groups.