☰ Year plan · Communication Technology

Judging new technology

Week 4 · Theme 1, Lesson 4 Evaluating Cutting-Edge Technology · 3 lessons
2

Seven questions to judge a product

ICT P6 Term 1, Theme 1: pp. 22–25
GoalUse seven questions to judge a product and match each question to its area.
New words
user experience · how it feels to use a product, from the first try to the lastcredible · believable and trustworthyaccessible · possible for many kinds of people to use, including people of determinationvaluable · it improves your life or helps you learn
Explanation

User experience means how it feels to use a product. Experts check it in seven areas. Each area is a question. Accessible: can people of determination use it? Credible: can the maker be trusted? Desirable: does it meet my need? Findable: if there is a problem, can I find the solution? Usable: is it easy to use? Useful: is it practical? Valuable: does it improve my life or help me learn? A product can be good in one area and weak in another. A robot that is very desirable but not usable will be left in a cupboard. A product that is easy to use but not credible may be unsafe. Use all seven questions, not only one, and give each a simple answer: yes, partly or no. Write down the reason in a few words, so someone else can check it.

AreaThe questionExample: a door lamp that flashes
accessibleCan people of determination use it?It flashes, so it works without hearing
credibleCan the maker be trusted?A teacher and the school club tested it
desirableDoes it meet my need?It tells me when a visitor is at the door
findableIf there is a problem, can I find the solution?A help sheet with big pictures is on the box
usableIs it easy to use?It has one big button
usefulIs it practical?Its battery lasts a long time
valuableDoes it improve my life or help me learn?I do not miss visitors and feel more independent
Worked examples
big buttoneasy to press
A big button on a TV remote is easy for Hany’s grandmother to press. Which area? Usable.
‘tested’by whom?not credible yet
A phone case says ‘clinic tested’, but no clinic is named and nobody can check. The area is credible, and the answer is ‘no’ until someone can confirm it.
talking watcha problemhelp sheet
A talking watch breaks. The box has a large-print sheet and a help line for a family member. The area is findable, and the answer is ‘yes’.
Class activity

Match game. Cut seven small papers and write the seven areas on them. Cut seven more and write the questions. Mix them, then match with a partner. After that, make up one new example for each area. Who finishes first?

Practice
1
Match: ‘Is it easy to use?’
2
Match: ‘Does it improve my life or help me learn?’
3
A pupil cannot hear. Which of the seven areas asks whether the product works for her?
4
Why should we use all seven questions, not only one?