GoalSay what makes the Earth’s magnetic field, and describe and evaluate an experiment that detects it.
New words
core · the centre of the Earth, mostly iron with some nickelouter core · the liquid layer of the core, whose movement is linked to the magnetic fieldmagnetise · to turn a magnetic material into a magnetreverse · for the north and south magnetic poles to swap places
Explanation
At one time people thought the Earth was a ball of magnetic rock. But rocks deep down are so hot that they lose their magnetism, so the field cannot come from them. Scientists now know that it comes from the core, which is mostly iron with some nickel, both magnetic metals. The outer core is liquid and flows slowly. Scientists think the heat and this movement make the field, although the exact explanation is still being worked out. The movement also explains why the poles drift and why the field has reversed many times. The last reversal was about 780 000 years ago, and rocks keep the evidence. To detect the field, hang a bar magnet from a thread so it stays level and wait until it settles: it points north and south. Move it elsewhere and repeat. The same direction in different places shows that the cause is the Earth and not something nearby. Such a compass is not practical for travel, because it swings about and nearby metal affects it.
Worked examples
Place in the room
Direction of the north pole
by the window
towards the north wall
by the door
towards the north wall
Why test in two parts of the room? Kenji hangs a magnet and it settles. He moves it across the room and it settles in the same direction. If the direction changed, a nearby magnet or steel object could be the cause. The same result in two places points to the Earth.
Place
Direction of the north pole
hall
north wall
bedroom
north wall
beside the fridge
towards the fridge
garden shed
north wall
Spotting an odd reading. Leo hangs a magnet in four places and notes where the north pole points. Three readings agree and one does not. The odd one was taken next to a fridge, so the fridge door magnet, not the Earth, caused it. Leo repeats that test away from the fridge.
Problem
Improvement
it swings for a long time
damp it with a bowl of water or wait longer
steel objects nearby change the direction
do the test away from metal and other magnets
the thread twists
use a thin thread and let it untwist
Evaluating the hanging magnet. It is a good model of a compass but it has weaknesses, and each one suggests an improvement.
Class activity
Hanging-magnet test, with an adult. Tie a thread round the middle of a bar magnet bigger than a coin, or use a long fridge magnet, so that it hangs level (a loop of paper can hold it). Hang it from a pencil taped to the edge of a table. Wait until it is still and mark the direction it points in with tape. Check it with a compass held far away. Repeat in a different spot in the room and then in another room. Always do this away from fridges, radiators and other magnets. Does the north pole always point the same way?
Practice
1
Scientists link the Earth’s magnetic field to one layer. Use the table to choose the layer and give two reasons.
Layer
State
Made of
crust
solid
rock
mantle
hot, slowly flowing
rock
outer core
liquid, flowing
iron and nickel
The outer core: it is liquid and flowing, and it is made of iron and nickel, which are magnetic metals.
2
Why can the Earth’s field not come from magnetic rocks near the surface?
Rocks deep in the Earth are so hot that they lose their magnetism, and anyway the field is much bigger than any near-surface rock.
3
A hanging magnet points to the north wall in one room, but in another room it points towards a large steel cupboard. What went wrong, and what should be done?
Room
Direction
A
north wall
B
towards the steel cupboard
The steel cupboard (or magnets inside it) is affecting the magnet. Move the experiment away from steel and other magnets and repeat it.
4
Give two reasons why a hanging-magnet compass would not be practical on a ship.
It would swing about with the motion of the ship, and steel in the ship would affect it.