GoalUse ideas about exothermic and endothermic changes to explain everyday heating and cooling products, and weigh their advantages and disadvantages.
New words
self-heating can · a can in which two chemicals are mixed to warm the foodcold pack · a pack that cools an injury because something inside takes in energyreusable · can be used againadvantage · a good point in favour of something
Explanation
We use exothermic reactions when we want warmth. A self-heating can keeps calcium oxide and water apart; when the seal is broken they react and warm the food. A disposable hand warmer holds iron that reacts with oxygen when the pouch is opened to the air. These products are useful when there is no fire or electricity, but they work only once, because the chemicals are used up. Endothermic changes are used to make things cool. A freezer pack cools an injury because the ice melts and takes in energy; it can go back in the freezer and be used again. A chemical cold pack has an inner bag of ammonium nitrate and an outer bag of water. Squeezing breaks the inner bag, and as the solid dissolves it takes in energy. It needs no freezer but is single use. Energy always flows from the warmer thing to the cooler one, so the injured area cools and the pack warms. The contents of a pack must never be opened or swallowed.
Product
What happens inside
Exothermic or endothermic?
Reaction or process?
self-heating can
calcium oxide reacts with water
exothermic
reaction
hand warmer
iron reacts with oxygen
exothermic
reaction
freezer ice pack
ice melts
endothermic
process
chemical cold pack
ammonium nitrate dissolves
endothermic
process
Worked examples
Product
Advantage
Disadvantage
self-heating can
hot food without a stove
used once; expensive; may heat unevenly
freezer ice pack
reusable
needs a freezer; melts
chemical cold pack
works anywhere, no freezer
single use; waste
Judging the products by their advantages and disadvantages helps people choose well. There is not one best product for every case.
Two sealed packs were squeezed and placed on a table. The temperature of pack X rises quickly to 52 °C and then slowly falls; pack Y falls quickly to 3 °C and then slowly rises. X is exothermic and Y is endothermic. Both return towards room temperature because energy flows between the pack and the room.
water seeps through the clay→water evaporates outside→energy taken from the pot→food inside stays cooler
In hot dry places, a clay pot keeps food cool without electricity. Water seeps through the clay and evaporates from the outside. Evaporation is endothermic, so it takes energy from the pot and its contents, which stay cooler than the air outside.
Class activity
Wet-cloth cooler, with an adult. Take two identical jars or cups and fill each with the same amount of warm tap water (about 40 °C, never boiling) prepared by the adult. Wrap one in a wet cloth or paper towel and the other in a dry one of the same size. Predict which will cool faster. Read both thermometers at the start and every 5 minutes for 20 minutes; do not stir with the thermometer. Record in a table and draw two lines on a graph. What did you change? What stayed the same? Which jar cooled most, and why? Why might a clay pot be better than a plastic box in a hot country?
Practice
1
Pack Z was squeezed and its temperature was recorded. Is the change exothermic or endothermic, and why does the temperature go back down after 35 °C?
Exothermic: the temperature rises to 35 °C. It then falls because thermal energy is lost to the cooler surroundings.
2
Explain why a disposable hand warmer cannot be switched off and used again next week.
Once the pouch is opened, the iron keeps reacting with oxygen until it is used up. The reaction cannot be stopped or reversed, so the warmer works once and then goes cold.
3
A school first-aid cupboard has no freezer. Which of the two packs in the table is the better choice, and why? Give one disadvantage of your choice.
Pack
Needs a freezer?
Reusable?
freezer ice pack
yes
yes
chemical cold pack
no
no
The chemical cold pack, because it works without a freezer. Its disadvantage is that it can be used only once, which adds waste.
4
Sort these: wax freezing, a chemical cold pack working, a hand warmer working, ice melting. Which are exothermic and which are endothermic?
Change
Exothermic or endothermic?
wax freezing
?
a chemical cold pack working
?
a hand warmer working
?
ice melting
?
Exothermic: wax freezing, hand warmer working. Endothermic: chemical cold pack working, ice melting.