GoalPlan a fair test of an exothermic reaction, reduce the loss of heat, and evaluate results with repeats and anomalies.
New words
preliminary work · a trial run to find suitable amounts and methods before the real testinsulation · a material that slows down the loss of heatrisk assessment · deciding what could go wrong and how to prevent itreliable · giving similar results when repeated
Explanation
To investigate an exothermic change, decide first what you will change (the independent variable), what you will measure (the dependent variable) and what you will keep the same. For a hand warmer you might change the number of layers of cloth round it, measure its highest temperature and keep the type of warmer, the room and the time the same. Preliminary work shows whether the change is big enough to measure. Thermal energy dissipates into the air and the container, so the measured rise is smaller than the real one; a polystyrene cup with a lid slows the loss. Repeat each test at least three times and calculate a mean. A reading far from the others is anomalous and should be checked. A risk assessment lists hazards, such as hot surfaces or splashes, and the precautions. A conclusion must match the data, and an evaluation says how to improve the method.
Kind of variable
Example in the hand-warmer test
change (independent)
number of layers of cloth round the warmer
measure (dependent)
highest temperature reached
keep the same (control)
type of warmer, room, time, thermometer
Worked examples
Three containers each held the same amount of warm water at 55 °C and were left for 10 minutes. The fall in temperature shows how much heat each lets out. The paper cup with a lid lost the least (4 °C), so it is the best insulator of the three.
Run
Rise (°C)
1
22
2
24
3
31 (anomalous?)
A set of repeats: 22, 24 and 23 °C. The mean = (22 + 24 + 23) ÷ 3 = 23 °C. If the three results were 22, 24 and 31, the 31 would be far from the others (anomalous): repeat it, and without it the mean is 23 °C.
Part of the plan
What to write
question
does the number of cloth layers change the highest temperature?
prediction
more layers, higher temperature, because less energy escapes
safety
adult opens the packaging; no pouch on bare skin; do not open the pouch
repeats
3 for each number of layers; calculate a mean
A plan for ‘Does the number of layers of cloth change the highest temperature of a hand warmer?’ lists the equipment, the variables, the number of repeats, the results table and the safety. An adult checks the plan before anyone starts.
Class activity
Which cup keeps heat in? With an adult. The adult pours the same amount of warm tap water (about 45 °C, never boiling) into three containers: a metal cup, a glass or ceramic mug, and a paper or foam cup. Predict which will keep the water warmest. Read the temperature at the start, then every 2 minutes for 10 minutes; do not stir with the thermometer. Record in a table and draw a line graph with three lines. Variables: what did you change and what did you keep the same? Rank the cups. Which cup is like the polystyrene cup used in school experiments, and why do scientists put a lid on it? Repeat the test another day and compare.
Practice
1
Leo wants to find out whether the number of cloth layers round a hand warmer changes the highest temperature. Complete the variables.
Kind of variable
In Leo’s test
change
?
measure
?
keep the same
?
Change: the number of cloth layers. Measure: the highest temperature. Keep the same: the type and age of the warmer, the room, the time and the thermometer.
2
Explain why a polystyrene cup with a lid gives a more accurate temperature rise than a metal cup without a lid.
Polystyrene is a good insulator, and the lid reduces heat loss through the top. Less thermal energy dissipates, so the measured rise is closer to the real rise.
3
Four repeats of the same test gave rises of 14, 15, 21 and 16 °C. Which result is anomalous? Calculate the mean of the others.
Run
Rise (°C)
1
14
2
15
3
21
4
16
21 °C is anomalous. Mean = (14 + 15 + 16) ÷ 3 = 15 °C.
4
A disposable hand warmer can reach about 50 °C. Give two safety rules for using one, with a reason for each.
Do not leave it against bare skin for long, because the heat can burn skin, so keep it inside a glove or pocket. Do not open or cut the pouch, because the contents can irritate skin and eyes. (Do not use it near a heater, or with babies who cannot move away.)