GoalUse moments to explain where muscles attach, read model-arm results, and build a model hand that shows how tendons work.
New words
pivot · the point about which a lever turns; in the arm it is the elbowload · the weight that is liftedmoment · the turning effect of a force: force × distance from the pivotanomalous result · a result that does not fit the pattern
Explanation
The forearm works as a lever: the elbow is the pivot, the load is in the hand and the biceps pulls on the radius close to the pivot. Moment = force × perpendicular distance from the pivot, so for the arm to stay still the muscle’s moment must equal the load’s. A 6 N load held 30 cm from the elbow has a moment of 180 N cm, so a muscle pulling 6 cm from the elbow must pull with 30 N, which is 5 times the load. A muscle fixed further from the elbow would need less force, but it would have to shorten much more to move the hand through the same angle. Muscles are strong but can only shorten by a small amount, so the real biceps is attached close to the elbow: a small shortening gives a big movement of the hand, at the cost of a big force. Models test such ideas, and their results can be checked for anomalous readings.
Worked examples
Distance of muscle from elbow
Force the muscle needs
3 cm
60 N
4 cm
45 N
5 cm
36 N
6 cm
30 N
10 cm
18 N
Moment of the load = 6 × 30 = 180 N cm. If the muscle is attached at different distances, the force it needs is 180 ÷ distance. The closer to the pivot, the greater the force.
A model arm was set up with a newton meter at different distances from the pivot to hold up the same load. The forces needed are plotted. Each distance × force is about 180 N cm, and the line falls steeply near the pivot.
In the model
In the real hand
straw pieces
finger bones
gaps between the straws
joints
string
tendon
your pulling hand
muscle in the forearm
A string-and-straw hand is a model of how tendons move fingers. Short pieces of straw are the finger bones, the gaps between them are the joints, and a string threaded through the straws is the tendon. Pulling the string bends the finger. The model has limits: real tendons are pulled by muscles that get shorter, you pull the string by hand, and a real finger has joints that stop it bending backwards.
Class activity
Near or far, with an adult. You need a bag of rice or sugar (about 1 kg), a loop of string and a clock. Sit with your upper arm resting on a table and your forearm held out level. The adult hangs the bag from the string loop on your forearm, first 5 cm from your elbow, then 25 cm from your elbow, for 10 seconds each time. Predict which feels harder to hold. Score the effort from 0 (very easy) to 5 (very hard) and repeat three times, resting between tests. Record the scores in a table and find the mean for each distance. What did you change and what did you keep the same? Use moments to explain the pattern. Stop if your arm hurts. The model hand: the adult cuts four straw pieces; thread a string through them, tie a knot at the tip and pull it.
Practice
1
A student holds a 4 N load 25 cm from the elbow. The biceps pulls 5 cm from the elbow. Calculate the force that the muscle must exert.
Moment of the load = 4 × 25 = 100 N cm. Force = 100 ÷ 5 = 20 N.
2
A robot arm lifts a 6 N load held 30 cm from its pivot. Cable A pulls 3 cm from the pivot and cable B pulls 9 cm from it. Calculate the force each cable needs, and say which one needs the longer pull for the same turn of the arm.
Moment of the load = 6 × 30 = 180 N cm. Cable A: 180 ÷ 3 = 60 N. Cable B: 180 ÷ 9 = 20 N. Cable B needs less force, but cable A needs the shorter pull, because it is close to the pivot; cable B must move further for the same turn.
3
One result in the table is anomalous. Which is it, and what should you do?
Distance (cm)
Force (N)
4
45
6
30
8
50
10
18
12
15
The force of 50 N at 8 cm. The other forces fall steadily as the distance grows (each distance × force is about 180 N cm), so 8 cm should give about 22 N. Repeat that measurement and check the set-up.
4
In the string-and-straw hand, what do the string, the straws and the gaps between the straws stand for? Give one way the model differs from a real hand.
The string is a tendon, the straws are finger bones and the gaps are joints. In a real hand a muscle gets shorter to pull the tendon, but in the model you pull the string yourself.