GoalPlan and carry out an investigation of the law of reflection, and use a graph and the idea of rough surfaces to explain the results.
New words
independent variable · the variable you choose to changedependent variable · the variable you measureline of best fit · a line drawn through the middle of the points on a graphdiffuse reflection · reflection from a rough surface, where rays bounce in many directions
Explanation
To test the law of reflection, aim a thin beam of light at a plane mirror at different angles. The independent variable is the angle of incidence and the dependent variable is the angle of reflection. Control variables are the same mirror and the same beam. Measure both angles from the normal with a protractor, and repeat for at least five angles. Plot the angle of reflection upwards and the angle of incidence along the bottom, and draw a line of best fit. The points fall close to a straight line through the origin, which shows that the two angles are equal. A result far from the line is anomalous and is checked again. A rough surface such as paper has normals pointing in many directions, so rays bounce in many directions (diffuse reflection) and no clear image forms. Each ray still obeys the law.
Worked examples
Angle of incidence (°)
Angle of reflection (°)
10
11
20
19
30
31
40
41
50
49
60
59
70
71
Kenji’s results are in the table. The angle of reflection is always within 2° of the angle of incidence. A difference of 1° or 2° is within the accuracy of reading a protractor, so the results support the law.
Problem
Improvement
wide beam
use a card with a narrow slit
mirror slightly off the line
check it with a ruler each time
reading the angle
look straight down; repeat and find the mean
Why the results are not exact: the beam of light has some width, the mirror may not be exactly on the line, and the protractor can be read to about 1°. Improvements: a thinner beam, a larger angle chart, and repeat readings to find a mean.
Two surfaces. A mirror reflects parallel rays so that they stay parallel and give a clear image. Paper has a rough surface with tiny bumps, so rays that arrive parallel leave in many directions and we see the paper from all sides but no image.
Class activity
Make an angle chart. Do this in a dim room with an adult; never use a laser pointer. On a sheet of paper draw a straight line about 20 cm long and a normal across its middle, then use a protractor to draw lines from the middle at 10°, 20°, 30° and so on each side of the normal. Stand a small flat mirror upright on the long line (an adult holds it, or use sticky putty). Shine a torch along the 20° line on the left, with the beam as narrow as you can make it, and see which line on the right the reflected beam follows. Repeat for five different lines and put the results in a table. Plot a graph. State the independent and dependent variables, and say which result you trust least and why.
Practice
1
In an investigation, a student measures these angles of incidence and reflection: 20° and 21°, 40° and 39°, 60° and 61°. What do the results show?
The two angles are equal (within about 1°), which supports the law of reflection.
2
A student measures angles of incidence 20°, 30°, 40°, 50° and 60° and gets angles of reflection 19°, 31°, 40°, 38° and 60°. Which result is anomalous, and what should she do?
The result for 50° (38°) is anomalous. She should repeat that measurement, check the normal and the mirror, and only then decide whether to leave it out.
3
A line of best fit goes through the origin at 45° to both axes. What does that tell you about the angles?
The two angles match at every point on the line.
4
Explain why a white wall does not give a clear image of a lamp, even though each light ray obeys the law of reflection.
The wall is rough, so its surface is made of tiny parts pointing in different directions. Parallel rays hit parts with different normals and bounce in many directions (diffuse reflection), so no clear image forms.