GoalExplain how experiments changed the model of the atom and why scientists check and share each other’s work.
New words
model · an idea or picture that helps us to explain what we cannot see directlydeflected · turned from its path so that it moves in a new directioncollaboration · scientists working together, sometimes in different countriespeer review · other scientists checking and testing the work before and after it is published
Explanation
Nobody can see an atom, so scientists build models and test them against evidence. In the late 1890s J. J. Thomson found the electron, a tiny negative particle. He pictured the atom as a ball of positive material with electrons scattered through it like raisins in a bun. Around 1911, Rutherford and his team fired fast, tiny particles at a very thin sheet of gold. If Thomson was right, the particles should pass through with only small bends. Instead most passed straight through, a few were deflected and about 1 in 8000 bounced almost straight back. The team decided that the atom is mostly empty space with a tiny, dense, positive nucleus at the centre. In 1932 James Chadwick showed that the nucleus also contains neutrons. Each step built on earlier work, and other scientists checked it by repeating the experiments, which is peer review. A model is kept only while it fits the evidence, and scientists are still improving our understanding with huge machines such as the Large Hadron Collider.
When
Scientist
What was found
late 1890s
J. J. Thomson
the electron
about 1911
Ernest Rutherford
the atom has a tiny nucleus
1932
James Chadwick
the neutron
Worked examples
Thomson’s model
Nuclear model
What was seen
most particles
pass through with small bends
pass straight through
pass straight through
a few particles
none strongly bent
a few are strongly bent
a few are deflected
bouncing back
never
very rarely
about 1 in 8000
The two models gave different predictions for the gold sheet. The result matched only one of them.
Observation
What the scientists concluded
most particles pass straight through
most of the atom is empty space
a few are deflected
there is a small, positive centre that repels them
very few bounce back
the centre is very dense and very small
What each observation showed about the gold atoms.
Model
What it explained
What it could not explain
Thomson’s
electrons exist
the gold-sheet results
Rutherford’s
the gold-sheet results
neutrons
today’s
protons, neutrons and electrons
scientists are still testing it
Each model explained some evidence, but not all of it. Models change when new evidence does not fit.
Class activity
Hidden-object game, with an adult. Lay a tray or board on four books so there is a gap beneath it. The adult secretly hides one or two objects (a cup, a ball of modelling clay) under the middle of the board where you cannot see. Roll a marble through the gap from many different directions, 20 times, and sketch each path in and out. Where do the marbles bounce, and where do they pass straight through? Use the paths to draw where you think the hidden objects are, and then lift the board to check. Keep marbles away from young children. How is this like the gold-sheet experiment? What is different?
Practice
1
What did J. J. Thomson discover and how did he picture the atom?
He discovered the electron. He pictured the atom as a ball of positive material with electrons scattered through it like raisins in a bun.
2
Out of 8000 particles fired at the gold, only about one bounced back. What does this small number tell scientists about the nucleus?
Out of about 8000 particles
What happens
almost all
pass straight through or bend very little
a few
are deflected
about 1
bounces almost straight back
It tells them that the nucleus is extremely small and dense, because only a particle that hits it almost head-on is thrown back. Most particles miss it.
3
Which discovery on the timeline came last, and what did it add to the model?
Year
Scientist
Found
1932
Chadwick
neutron
1897
Thomson
electron
1911
Rutherford
nucleus
The neutron (1932, Chadwick) came last. It showed that the nucleus contains neutral particles as well as protons.
4
Why is it useful that scientists in different countries check and repeat each other’s work?
Repeating the work shows whether the results are reliable, mistakes are found, and ideas are tested from different points of view. Working together also lets scientists share skills and equipment.