GoalWeigh the benefits and harms of insecticides, judge the evidence and possible bias, and evaluate an investigation about the effect of an insecticide.
New words
benefit · a good result of doing somethingharm · damage done to living things or to the environmentbias · a way of presenting information that unfairly favours one sidealternative · another way of doing the same job
Explanation
Decisions about chemicals are never simple. A persistent insecticide can protect people from diseases carried by mosquitoes and protect crops, which helps to feed people. But it can also harm fish, birds and pollinating insects, and because it spreads far from where it was used the harm may be far away too. Some crops depend on pollinators. Scientists and governments weigh the benefits against the harms using evidence. There are alternatives: biodegradable insecticides, bed nets, draining standing water, or crop varieties that resist pests. Each has costs and limits. When you read claims, ask who is saying it, what evidence they give and whether they gain from you believing it. A company selling a spray may play down the risks, while independent scientists publish their methods and data so that other scientists can check them. A model such as the bead game helps us to understand the idea, but it has limits and cannot predict real amounts.
Benefits of a persistent insecticide
Harms of a persistent insecticide
kills the mosquitoes that carry disease
stays in the environment for years
protects crops, so more food
builds up along food chains
needs spraying only occasionally
harms birds, fish and pollinating insects
often cheap
spreads far from where it was used
Worked examples
Square
1
2
3
4
5
Mean
sprayed
4
6
5
3
7
5
unsprayed
9
11
10
12
8
10
Evaluating an experiment. Scientists tested whether spraying pesticide X changes the number of kinds of insect in a meadow. They counted the kinds of insect found in 10 minutes in five sprayed squares and five unsprayed squares of grass, each 1 m by 1 m. Sprayed mean = (4 + 6 + 5 + 3 + 7) ÷ 5 = 5. Unsprayed mean = (9 + 11 + 10 + 12 + 8) ÷ 5 = 10. The results support the idea that spraying lowers the number of kinds of insect. To improve: use more squares, count at different times and days, and choose squares with the same type of grass.
Statement
Who said it
Possible bias?
‘Our spray is completely safe for wildlife.’
the company that sells the spray
yes, it wants to sell more
‘Fish from the lake contain 3 ppm of the chemical.’
an independent laboratory that published its methods
unlikely, others can check the method
‘All sprays should be banned.’
a campaign group
possibly, it may leave out the benefits
Judging statements. Evidence matters, and so does who gives it.
The same build-up happens with other persistent pollutants. Waste metal from an old mine washes into a river and is not broken down. Mud worms take it in, small fish eat many worms and an otter eats many fish. The otter is more at risk than the worm, because the concentration is highest at the top of the chain.
Class activity
Read the label, with an adult. Find one product in your home that kills pests (an insect spray, an ant killer or a flea treatment for a pet), or ask the adult to show you a picture of one online. Do not open it or spray it. Copy down what it kills, any warnings about animals, water or children, and how the container should be thrown away. Who wrote the label, and might they want you to buy the product? Write two benefits and two harms of using it, and one other way to deal with the pest that needs no chemical (for example a fly screen or keeping food covered). Wash your hands if you handled the container.
Practice
1
Scientists counted butterfly visits to flowers over 10 minutes. Calculate the mean for each group and state what the results suggest. Give one way to improve the investigation.
Group
Flower 1
Flower 2
Flower 3
Flower 4
sprayed
3
5
4
4
unsprayed
9
11
10
10
Sprayed: (3 + 5 + 4 + 4) ÷ 4 = 4. Unsprayed: (9 + 11 + 10 + 10) ÷ 4 = 10. Sprayed flowers had fewer visits. Improvement: use more flowers, repeat on several days and keep the type of flower the same.
2
A company that sells an insecticide says it has no effect on bees. Why should you ask for more evidence before you believe this?
The company wants to sell the product, so it may be biased. An independent test with published methods and results, which other scientists can check, would be more trustworthy.
3
Give one benefit and one harm of a persistent insecticide, and suggest one way to get the benefit with less harm.
Benefit: it kills mosquitoes that carry disease. Harm: it builds up along food chains and harms predators. Less harm: use a biodegradable insecticide, bed nets or draining standing water.
4
A fish-eating bird and a plant-eating insect both live at a lake where a toxin has been released. Which is more at risk? Use the chart.
The fish-eating bird, because the concentration of the toxin is highest at the top of the food chain (4 ppm), and the insect has a much lower concentration (0.05 ppm).